TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Government WILL publish report of Expert Group on abortion ruling

James Reilly wants to publish the report on the A, B and C ruling after it’s discussed by ministers next Tuesday morning.

Image: Julien Behal/PA Wire

THE GOVERNMENT has agreed to publish the full report of its Expert Group into the European Court of Human Rights ruling in the A, B and C case.

The report was submitted to the Department of Health last week, but the Government had not committed to publishing it – preferring instead to digest its contents before deciding whether legislative changes were needed following the ruling.

The European Court had ruled in 2010 that the rights of an Irish woman who had previously suffered from cancer, and who wished to terminate a subsequent pregnancy over fears her cancer would return, were breached by Ireland’s failure to offer clear legislation in the area of abortion.

The Government has now agreed to publish the document, however, after Sinn Féin’s Dáil motion called on the government to publish the report without delay.

An amendment to Sinn Fein’s motion, proposed by James Reilly – which will be voted upon before any other amendments, and before a vote is called on the motion itself – would see the Dáil acknowledge “the complexity and sensitivity of the issues involved”.

The wording put forward by Reilly “supports the Minister for Health’s decision to bring the Report to Government on Tuesday, 27th November and his recommendation that it be then published immediately”.

The wording essentially confirms that the government has already agreed to Reilly’s recommendation, and will publish the full contents of the report after ministers get to see it for the first time next Tuesday.

Reilly’s amendment to the motion also, however, removes the clause calling on the Government to introduce immediate legislation for abortion under the X case – which Sinn Féin’s original motion demanded – and so the Government’s decision will not remove all of the intensity from the Dáil debates over the coming two nights.

The news comes after Enda Kenny told the Dáil during Leaders’ Questions that the three representatives from University College Hospital, Galway, would be removed from the HSE’s independent inquiry into the death of Savita Halappanavar.

Halappanavar’s widower Praveen had said he would not work with the group as long as it contained representatives of the hospital where Savita was being treated when she died.

Read: TDs won’t get to vote on Sinn Féin’s abortion motion. Here’s why

Read next:

Comments (15 Comments)

  • LarBren1, what has that got to do with publishing the report and do you agree that women should be forced to travel to the UK because of a grey area in Irish law ? Out of site out of mind yeah ?

    Reply
  • Why wait till next Tuesday to publish the report?

    Reply
  • JakkiB 20/11/12 #

    They might not have finished writing it yet *Wink*Wink* ;-)

    Reply
  • The reluctance and the delay in publishing to the electorate an expert Report paid for by the electorate is simply explained. The electorate needs to be carefully managed, as one would manage children or those who are not mature to read the Report cold. The spin doctors need time to put the right complexion on the Report, interpret it for the plebs and tell us what to think. If you think that the Irish electorate has become disenchanted with its elected politicians, this is nothing compared to the dismissiveness and derogatory view of the electorate expressed in private by some of the Government Ministers. It’s a natural and predictable side effect of power and hard to resist.

    So, patience please. Wait for your lords and masters to curve and spin the message. Lay aside your critical faculties, trust your rulers and remember you live in a representative, not a participative democracy. You are not ready for a Referendum or real expression of democratic will.

    Please behave yourselves, toe the line and let your betters look after this. Damage limitation must transcend the public good and justice as well as the right to life of women. Know your place. Independent thought is not a policy. Ireland is the safest place in the world for maternal safety and our politicians are truly unequalled in their moral probity, political integrity and their sense of humanity before all else. The fact that In return for this I’m hoping to be permitted to buy the GPO and open an amusement arcade there should not cause you to doubt my wise words.

    What is the difference between an FG TD and a foetus? A foetus has the potential to become intelligent and to develop independent thought.

    Reply
  • looks like Obi Wan Kenobi using the “farce” .

    Reply
  • alan 20/11/12 #

    why have the govt to see it ‘first’? because they have better powers of comprehension?

    there is no reason not to publish it now. the public are able to read and to discriminate for themselves.

    Reply
  • How do you know that the government weren’t going to publish the report anyway? Your article seems to suggest they did it as a result of the SF motion, have they said that?

    Reply
  • The Sinn Féin leadership still committed to sneaking British style abortion laws into Ireland through the back door.

    Reply

Add New Comment