TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Thursday 20 June, 2013

Redistribution of wealth ‘a foreign concept’, says Mitt Romney

The Republican candidate for US president says seeking the spread of wealth has made government become too big and too expensive.

Mitt Romney shrugged off the controversy over secretly-filmed videos as he visited Utah for fundraising events yesterday.
Mitt Romney shrugged off the controversy over secretly-filmed videos as he visited Utah for fundraising events yesterday.
Image: Rick Bowmer/AP

REPUBLICAN PRESIDENTIAL candidate Mitt Romney has said his Democratic opponent Barack Obama believes government should “take from some to give to the others”, in a defence of his remarks characterising welfare recipients as “victims” who believe in an automatic entitlement to government assistance.

In an interview with Fox News, Romney said he viewed the automatic redistribution of wealth as a “foreign concept” and that there is a “great divide” among Americans on the subject – adding that a growing federal government, driven in part by people who demand its support, had jeopardised the country.

“It’s a pathway that looks more European than American in my view. And it’s a pathway some Americans are drawn to,” Romney said. He said people who pay no income taxes would be unlikely to support his campaign because his plan to cut those taxes across the board wouldn’t help them.

The Republican presidential candidate was reinforcing remarks he made at a $50,000-a-plate fundraiser in May, which was secretly filmed with footage published by US news website Mother Jones this week.

Romney’s campaign spent part of Monday trying to mitigate fallout from the video, in which he tells donors that 47 per cent of Americans “believe they are victims” and that his job as president wouldn’t be to “worry about those people.”

‘Off the cuff’

The former Massachusetts governor offered no apologies for his remarks in a news conference on Monday night, merely saying his feelings were not “elegantly stated” and were spoken “off the cuff.”

He said the remarks showed a contrast between Obama’s “government-centered society” and his belief in a “free-market approach”. ”Of course, I want to help all Americans, all Americans, have a bright and prosperous future,” Romney told reporters.

The video’s emergence came as Romney advisers tried to reassure party leaders and donors about Romney’s strategy amid concerns that the race could be slipping away.

A second video, published yesterday, saw Romney argue that Palestinians “have no interest” in peace with Israel.



Responding with an appearance on the Late Show with David Letterman, Obama said the one thing he had learned in office “is that you represent the entire country” – adding: “There are not a lot of people out there who think they are victims.”

At the same time, Obama’s campaign released a new ad saying that a prospective President Romney might seek the elimination of a series of tax breaks used by millions of middle-class Americans.

“Mitt Romney, he’s so focused on big business and tax cuts for the wealthy, it seems like his answers to middle class America are just tough luck,” says a woman in the commercial.

Read: Romney stands over comments that Obama voters are ‘dependants’

More: Romney caught on tape… who else has fallen foul of hidden recordings?

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (59 Comments)

  • So, if Romney became president, he claims that he wouldn’t care about almost half the American population. I don’t know whether to give him credit for his alarming honesty, stupidity or arrogance.

    Reply
    • Jason Bourne. Of course. You have stated the obvious. But , even you would see that there is a bit of a quantum leap in going from supporting Israel and say the Palestinians do not want peace. American support for Israel has been the billions of dollars they supply, and , sometimes in the UN.

      Reply
  • What a plonker .. a dangerous one at that.

    Reply
    • Oh Romney you’re such a plonker!
      And Romney (the surname) is a foreign concept!

      Reply
    • Apart from his political views, the man is either incredibly ignorant or insincere. He talks of how people in America have 95% of life set up for them, as if America is a stand alone country for an individual’s prosperity, and berates the fact that some Americans want to have a society closer to European standards of equity and social provision. The fact is that America comes way down on social mobility in the developed world, and considering the completely inequitable and unreachable costs of healthcare, property tax and education in the U.S., it is fair to say that the average citizen in any of Europe’s fully developed economies is probably significantly better off than the average American, despite the economic implosion that occured in Europe as a result of unregulated financial activities which were bailed out by the elected government expenditure, Romney so despises. Only an Idiot or a completely self interested person whose financial returns are best represented by Romney could vote for him. Maybe American needs to get worse before it can get better , could you imagine this man having a chance of electability in any other developed democracy. The concept of “American Exceptionalism” is avowed by those who know the least of the world around them in the US, Ignorance and Arrogance is really hampering the lives of average americans.

      Reply
    • This man and his supporters want to turn the clock back a hundred years on workers rights and entitlements and basic society.

      Reply
    • And his closer to Europe nonsense, in “Europe” (fully developed economies) you have a social floor with regard to health, you have far greater access to Education than the US, social mobility is higher and contrary to the essence of Romney’s arguments it is still full of Billionaires and high concentrations of wealth, the ignorant right in the U.S would like you to believe that Europe is some 2nd world state devoid of opportunity or extravagance, he is either ignorant or insincere but obviously wrong.

      Reply
  • Spoken by a true tax dodging capitalist.

    Reply
  • By Mitt Romney’s logic Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan were all socialists who were fans of “foreign concepts” They all raised taxes for higher earners in their times of office and Nixon presided over a very progressive tax system. Mitt Romney clearly only cares about his billionaire crony and the wealthiest 1% of America. He couldnt give a damn about the 99% of Americans. I hope that Americans aren’t foolish enough to elect this tosser

    Reply
  • Yeah it’s way better to just get richer and let people die in the streets!!!

    Reply
  • The irony of a caucasian American moaning about foreign concepts… especially while running in a democratic election!

    Reply
  • And we all thought Bush was bad

    Reply
  • “I want to help all Americans”…yes,particularly all rich Americans.So these parasite politicians are not exclusive to this Island of ours.

    Reply
  • Cough splutter (chokes on tea) what $50,000 a plate !

    Reply
  • This lunatic makes George Bush look like mother Teresa.

    Reply
  • A business giant should never be in the running….only thing on his mind is acquisition of wealth and prestige.

    Reply
  • The ‘red scare’ sweeps America once again, the eighties are back! Reaganesque mis-interpretations of foreign policy allied with domestic policies to protect the upper crust. His take on the Palestinian crisis would be hilarious if it wasn’t so scary.

    Reply
  • What a surprise! This is the same party that gave us two Bushes and Reagan, all good God fearing Christians!

    Reply
  • Thank God he didnt choose Sarah Palin as his running mate, now there is a scary combination.

    Reply
  • He is correct though. Jesus was not American. He was a Roman.

    Reply
  • This man must have the most dedicated and well paid team of spin doctors in the world. He flip flops on every comment he makes ‘off the cuff’. Thats practically his catchphrase

    His campaign will implode worse than Sean Gallagher.

    Reply
    • He does have a dedicated spin team , it’s called the republican party , hence it was straight on to the Republican propanganda machine Fox news yesterday trying to manage the fall out …..they’ve been spinning hard to stop any focus that he’s a Mormon hatchet man worth millions of dollars ( by far the wealthiest guy looking to become president ) and it’s reasonable to assume what policies and directin hell push America if he wins.

      Reply
  • Mick B 19/09/12 #

    It doesn’t matter who is elected. They are just puppets for the real decision makers.
    There is a documentary called ‘The Deception of Obama’. I’d recommend it to anyone that is interested in finding out what is really going on in the World today. It is frightening!
    I fully expect to get red thumbs for this comment, so go ahead. :-)

    Reply
  • Couldn’t expect anything else from a Republican in fairness, they’re very much like our own Fianna Fail, there’s no such thing as a good one

    Reply
  • Not sure about the rest of you guys but I’d prefer to keep as much of my earnings as possible rather than having it taxed and wasted on on a bloated public service – that’s hardly a ‘lunatic’ idea or “worse than Bush”. Good grief, that takes some level of hyperbole even if you’re a committed socialist.

    Having said that, Romney’s comments on that leaked tape – even if he firmly believes them – are not presidential and he may have already lost the election because of them.

    Reply
  • The scary thing is all these people really believe in what they are saying!Romney didnt apologise he just went on to explain his logic..fascist?And we welcome US corporations and politicians to this country with open arms..how much are they influencing policy in Ireland via IBEC etc.

    Reply
    • Do you mean the American companies who create jobs in this country?

      Reply
    • Its a complicated issue.They bring jobs but they use our tax system to avoid billions in taxes.Irelands biggest Foreign Direct Investor into and out of the country is…Bermuda.Obama recently called Ireland a tax haven.This is the reality behind our multinationals in Ireland,they see Ireland as a place to avoid taxes and are given full state support to do so.Its common knowledge in business.
      The IFSC & The Shadow Banking System with Dr Jim Stewart,t, Senior Lecturer in Finance, Trinity College
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyf7ppw3-lc
      But also i meant behind the scenes what kind of conversations are really going on between the fundamentalists and how is this feeding into policy in our universities and local government..

      Reply
  • Romney for four years!

    Reply
  • Redistribution of wealth is a tenant of socialism, a tape was released yesterday of Obama stating that he “believes in redistribution” but do you think you guys would report that?!

    Reply
    • Redistribution of wealth is a tenet of capitalism. It occurs when one buys shares on the stock market.

      Reply
    • The word is tenet not tenant.Every tax system in the world is designed to redistribute wealth.In the 70s the higher tax rate in America was 70% but it was never called a socialist country.It was a capitalist country with a progressive tax system.

      Reply
    • The 70% tax was under Jimmy Carter and it was socialism (just as the 75% tax in France is socialism only it’s framed as “progressive tax), he ended up a failed, one term president much like the current chump in the White house will.

      Reply
    • Carter was president at the end of the 70s.There were 2 republican presidents before him who had the same top rate of tax.

      Reply
    • Oh God Cian, commiserations! Not only on your views and their ignorance but on the fact that you are one of only two ppl in Ireland that uses the word “chump” and the other is John McGuirk. Although I’d imagine that yed be great bedfellows given ye share similar idiotic beliefs.

      Reply
    • Ignorance and Arrogance Cian, it seems you are an ideal candidate for manipulation.

      Reply
    • You kind of struggle to grasp points…..You should keep your head down and stop spouting rubbish.Check your data…and confirm its factual. Learning is an ongoing aspect of our lives…All those red thumbs?….its not you, it’s what you ‘say’ ! Hope springs eternal…

      Reply
    • That socialism crap is evil. Sure who wants equality of the sexes, sexualities, races and creeds; a job for every person; education for everyone; and a home for every person who needs it?

      Reply
    • “During the election campaign, French President François Hollande threatened to slap an income tax rate of 75 percent on high earners. Since then, wealthy French have been looking for ways to get themselves and their money out of the country. And nowhere looks more attractive than millionaire-friendly London.

      In South Kensington, the epicenter of elegant French exiles, the bon vivant can get all life’s necessities. There are French creperies, fromageries and rotisseries, as well as French bookstores and bakeries. There are French-speaking dentists, plumbers and tax accountants, not to mention French schools. There is even a French cinema and a radio station. The French’s tricolor flag is as visible here as the Union Jack, and the district secretly sees itself as the 21st arrondissement of Paris.”
      Der Spiegel

      Reply

Add New Comment