TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Kelleher: Dept of Health ringfence claim “strikes fear into me”

He made the comment while questioning Minister Kathleen Lynch on the axing of the Mobility Allowance and Motorised Transport Grant.

Minister Kathleen Lynch
Minister Kathleen Lynch
Image: Oireachtas.ie

MINISTER OF STATE Kathleen Lynch was questioned this afternoon on last night’s decision to axe the mobility allowance and motorised transport grant and replace them with an as-yet-undecided alternative.

During topical issues in the Dáil, Deputies Billy Kelleher and Caomhghín Ó Caoláin both questioned the Minister on the decision, with Ó Caoláin saying he believed “the only conclusion to be drawn is this is another cutback by another name”.

Kelleher said:

When I hear the Department of Health saying they will ringfence funding, you know, it strikes fear into me. Because last year we were given a commitment that mental health funding was ringfenced and it wasn’t, it was snaffled and put into the budget

Kelleher added:

If the best brains in the Department of Health couldn’t come up with it in two years, you are now asking an independent review to come up with a solution in four months.
What should have happened was the scheme should have been allowed to continue for time being, and an independent review group would have been set up to come up with the solutions to the problems…
It’s a heartless cut, Minister.

Lynch said the issue should have been dealt with long ago.

Disappointed

Seán Moynihan, CEO of ALONE, said they are “hugely disappointed” and they are demanding that the new scheme to be put in place will allow equal access to all sectors of society where a need has been assessed.

A figure of between €170 – €300million has been quoted in order to allow access to the scheme to over 65s.  We’re unclear as to how these figures were arrived at, as this would equate to approximately 100,000 older people applying for the scheme, which we completely reject.  We work with hundreds of older people on a daily basis and are aware of only two or three people in receipt of this allowance.

Concluding, he commented: “What we’re hearing is that there is a slightly ageist agenda, and we’re calling on government to allow all those who are assessed as having a need, no matter what age, to have access to the scheme.”

Fianna Fáil Spokesperson on Social Protection, Willie O’Dea TD, says the news is “another slap in the face for the most vulnerable”.

The Center for Independent Living said it is appalled at the announcement. Michael McCabe, chairperson of Center for Independent Living, described it as “an absolutely outrageous attack on the rights of people with disabilities and flies in the face of the National Disability Strategy”.

He said that “instead of accommodating the inclusion of people with disabilities in the community this will lead to greater exclusion and isolation especially for those living in rural areas”.

Read: ‘Every other option was illegal’ – Minister defends disability payments cut>

Read: ‘A sick bureaucratic monster’ – Department slammed after disability payments axed>

Read next:

Comments (42 Comments)

  • Kathleen, you’ll be lucky if your family vote for you in the next election although you’ll probably run to the hills with your big fat pension.

    Reply
  • Kathleen, I doubt you even believe it yourself. Nothing is ringfenced. There is no money there to ring fence. It’s been spent, its gone. We gave it to Sean Fitzpatrick to buy magic beans.

    Reply
  • Is there any group in society apart from themselves they haven’t attacked?

    Reply
  • The politics and those practicing it in this country ‘strikes fear into me’
    It’s a deplorable act – one of the many, many, many of the like carried out on societies most vulnerable by successive governments. Shame is obviously a bi-word these days.

    Reply
  • More cuts from the party that brought you the property tax

    Reply
  • Another nail in the coffin for this government it will be very interesting to see how many will take their big fat pensions and retire and end up in the same boat as Bertie Aherne and the rest of his friends from the pervious government

    Reply
    • MrKnow 27/02/13 #

      @Kenneth, bertie and his gang of con artist did really well for themselves, they retired on huge made-for-life pensions and landed on there feet with careers. They never even answered or paid for destroying this country and its people, and don’t forget… look what party is leading in the polls for the next election!

      Reply
  • there was a very nicely cut coat and red shoes walking into the dail today, whilst i sat outside in my wheelchair protesting, yep.
    i didnt feel nice in my scruff nor the bucket the hse gave me for a wheelchair, a reconstituted sick clapped out museum piece it is. i think revolt is the only way. surely there was more than twin and myself who heard this news last night? where were you today then? all working? too sick? we need far more people out there being expressive not sitting at a laptop being passively aggressive, this way is the easy way. i am in utter fear of what will happen next and when kathleen expresses herself as ‘agonizing’ over this….no Kathleen Lynch, you dont agonize over disability cuts, we agonize as we are the disabled being cut. if you have to make a decision over heating for the house, versus ‘can i afford this to help keep my eyesight? YES, thats agonizing, and thats what i do all the time. a disability pension only goes so far Minister for Health with special responsibility for disability and mental health. i am mental with this agonizing and thats a bloody fact.

    Reply
  • Maybe now the apparently gormless general population of Ireland, gormless because they appear reluctant to stand up for themselves, will stand up for THE most vulnerable section of Irish society and in the process restore some credibility to themselves. And about frugging time……. Deep within the Irish psyche we are a stoic and compassionate people……… Time now folks for the compassion to find voice. Besides, the stoicism exhibited in recent years has taken a greater toll than the U-know whoze could dare believe. If this is not the time to say stop then give it up……. you have new masters.

    Reply
  • ANGLO IRISH BANK HAD PRIVATE CONTRACTS WITH GERMAN AND FRENCH BANKS…..not a word was mentioned in those contracts about the Irish citizen being responsible for any liability for those loans in anyway shape or form….60 BILLION has been pushed on us illegally through agents in our government working for the Troika and the ECB , so are we going to take this bull** or are we going to say NO ?

    Reply
  • So they can’t afford 10.1 Million for the disabled of the country for mobility allowance, but yet for 266 people they can manage to have travel expenses of 7.2 Million…when are people gonna fight back!

    Reply
  • An interesting example of the law of unintended consequences – a complaint is made to the Ombudsman that the Mobility Allowance Scheme is illegal because it excludes people over 66 years of age.

    Rather than extend the scheme to everyone which the government can not afford, it is forced to completely abolish the scheme so it is no longer in breach of the Equal Status Act.

    Reply
  • Utterly sickens me to hear FF to speak like they are the defenders of the down trodden when any simpleton can see they’d do the exactly same thing if, God forbid, they ever get back into power. You got us into this s*it pit FF…you have demnstrated you are utterly incapable of getting us out of it. Just like the current crop…

    Reply
  • I thought this government promised to look after the most vunerable in this country how come they didn’t tell the public what they really had planned once they had there massive wages and pensions sorted

    Reply
  • This government is devoid of any humanity. They are a disgrace to this country. Enda is the most sniveling , two-faced p***k I have ever come across!!

    Reply
  • Kellehers scared? The thought of Fianna Fáil getting back into power scares me shitless!

    Reply
  • Kathleen should be ashamed, especially considering the fact had she not made a full recovery, it could so easily be her on the receiving end of these cutbacks now: http://www.medicalindependent.ie/6797/ready_for_the_challenge

    Reply
  • You are inviting more taxation Kelleher. Is that your policy? If the money is not there it is not there. Are you seriously saying we need more taxation? If we cannot afford these allowances how are you proposi mg the money be made available. Tell the nation you want more taxation and stop playing party politics with an important issue.

    Reply
  • The Irish bull. Where do you get the money? I take it for your comment that you are willing to pay additional tax , but , do you really think the people can afford to pay more tax? The cause is mighty but people are stretched. The idea that the State can just magic up the money is outdated. How much cash are you personally prepared to cough up to replace these grants, each week?

    Reply
    • How about makin corporations cough up seeing as they wont even pay the 12.5% tax they are supposed to pay and how about cutting the salaries of the high end earners and special allowances for the political elite and how about nationalising our gas and oil ???…..shall i continue ??

      Reply
    • Tua,
      Thats the corporations that employ hundreds of thousands up and down the country… Give me a break….I work for these companies and know first hand that our corporation tax is a massive insentive.. I hear this kind of babble from Boyd Barrett all the time… rediculous.
      Rory is bang on with his comment.

      Reply
    • They are very kind to employ a man who can’t even spell incentive. Is this a quid pro quo for them paying around 4% ?

      Reply
    • Rory , can you pay my bils ? I have a private contract with the ESB and you have to pay my bill….just like ANGLO they had private contracts with European banks and we are paying those bills, so will you pay my bills which you have no liability for ?

      Reply
    • M Bowe 28/02/13 #

      An actual tax take of 0.14% is a joke. As for them paying wages etc that a red herring. Our 12.5% rate is lowest in Europe by far. So implementing the full rate would not send these companies elsewhere. Ur stance is “half a loaf” politics. Except we ain’t getting half a loaf or even the crumbs of the corporate tables.

      Reply
  • Think you will find that like every other grant in this country… a huge cohort of those getting it should not be… same goes for carers etc… I commend the HSE for reviewing every case and giving the money to those that deserve it. I wish people were half as critical of the huge volume of people out there playing the system…

    Reply

Add New Comment