Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
LAST UPDATE | 5 Oct
APPEAL COURT JUDGES in Belfast have reserved their judgment in a legal challenge over the Drumcree parading dispute.
The residents today challenged a decision of a High Court judge – made in the early hours of Sunday, 27 September – to refuse leave to apply for a judicial review of the commission’s determination to permit an Orange Order march down the predominantly nationalist road in Portadown later that day.
Residents in the largely nationalist area around the road – backed by Sinn Féin, the SDLP and People Before Profit – are opposed to the parade, which was due to start last Sunday morning, and unsuccessfully fought the decision in court.
The court today considered a fresh legal challenge, hearing submissions today from barristers representing Garvaghy Road residents and the Parades Commission.
At the end of submissions, Judge Siobhan Keegan said: “We will have to think about the submissions, both in writing and orally.”
She said that the judges’ decision is reserved, and a date for a decision cannot be given right now, but “hopefully” would be “within a swift enough timeframe”.
Earlier, Denise Kiley KC, representing the Garvaghy Road residents, said that the parade “one of the most polarising parades in the history of Northern Ireland”.
She told the court that the Parades Commission had a duty to promote an understanding of parading and it had failed to explain why it had reached its determination to permit the parade, particularly as it was the first time in 28 years it had not been banned.
Outlining the basis of the appeal court challenge, she added: “There is a public interest in ensuring that the Parades Commission – a body charged with making these significant decisions on contentious parading issues – comes to correct and lawful determinations.”
Kiley said the Parades Commission failed to “properly weigh” what the police had told it about the potential for disorder if the parade was given the go ahead.
She said the commission’s assertion that there was no specific information from police about a risk of violence did not fully reflect what a senior commander had told it.
Kiley said PSNI Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson had told the commission while police had no clear intelligence about any planned disorder he had also stressed that officers were dealing with an “unclear picture” and that, as a result, police were planning for various scenarios – from a peaceful passing of the parade to an outbreak of violent disorder.
Kiley said the commission’s subsequent conclusion that there was no specific information about the prospect of disorder was “only part of the picture”.
She said the commission had therefore reached an “irrational conclusion”.
Tony McGleenan KC, representing the Parades Commission, said the residents were attempting to “make some forensic play” in asserting a difference between what the police told the commission and what the commissioners then recorded as the police assessment.
He said “one accurately reflects the other”.
He said legal jurisprudence placed a positive obligation on facilitating the right of assembly, and the residents’ contention that the commission had made a legal error “doesn’t bear scrutiny”.
The barrister said that legal precedent made clear that considerable “deference” should be afforded to statutory decision-making bodies.
On the residents’ case that the commission should have explained why it was changing its determination after almost 30 years of prohibiting the parade, McGleenan insisted the commissioners had explained why.
He said the reason lay in the fact that what was proposed by the Orange lodge was very different to what had been applied for before, including in respect of numbers, time of year and symbols and emblems displayed.
McGleenan added: “The folk memory of what happened in the 1990s relates to something that’s categorically different.”
McGleenan also said that the determination to permit a limited parade should be “read it its totality”, as “there is a grave danger of cherry-picking sentences here and sentences there to suggest a wrong legal test or a misdirection, or that something hasn’t actually been considered.”
He said police had given an assurance to the commissioners that they had the capacity to deal with any disorder that may have been triggered if a parade was permitted.
He insisted that the commission was “fully briefed” by police on the uncertainty around what might happen.
Meanwhile, Irish rap trio Kneecap visited Portadown to show support for the residents.
Móglaí Bap, Mo Chara and DJ Próvaí – Naoise Ó Cairealláin, Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh, and JJ Ó Dochartaigh – went to a local school before meeting residents at Drumcree Community Centre on Sunday.
They were then swarmed by fans of all ages as they were led up the Garvaghy Road by the spokesman for the residents’ coalition, Breandán Mac Cionnaith.
The Belfast-based stars posed for selfies as volunteer stewards tried to keep fans off the road and allow the progress of vehicle traffic.
Hundreds of people had lined the street in advance of their arrival, but a stage which has been used for speeches in recent days was covered off and the three musicians did not perform or formally address the crowd.
They stopped briefly in a tent at the junction which leads up to Drumcree Parish Church – which is where the Orange Order is aiming to march from – before turning around and leaving the area by car.
In a statement to the Press Association after the visit, the trio said: “Kneecap support the residents of Garvaghy Road, they’re a determined and strong community.
“No community should have to live with sectarian intimidation, racism or hatred. Not here, not now, not anywhere.”
They were accompanied by their solicitor Darragh Mackin, who also represents the residents, as well as their manager Daniel Lambert and Irish folk singer Radie Peat.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
have your say