TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 14 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Galway nursing home taken over after failure to address ‘risk issues’

Owen Riff nursing home in Oughterard, Galway has been taken over by the HSE after an unannounced inspection by HIQA.

Image: Niall Carson/PA Wire via AP

Updated: 21:20

OWEN RIFF NURSING home, located in Oughterard in Galway, has been taken over by the Health Service Executive (HSE).

The two-storey centre had 22 residents in long-term care, with space for 18 more. It was taken over by the HSE as a result of an unannounced inspection by the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA), which took place on 20 and 21 April 2012.

During the inspection, staffing levels at the home were found to be lower than reported during a previous inspection, while “nutrition and weight loss, falls management, wound management and access and referral to allied health professionals” also remained on a list of concerns.

Following these findings, an order was made by Galway District Court to cancel the registration of the home, with the Health Service Executive (HSE) requested to make alternative arrangements for the residents. An appeal, which was made on behalf of the Owen Riff nursing home, was withdrawn on 31 July 2012.

Staffing

Where staffing was concerned, the report stated:

Inspectors found the person in charge to be disorganised and they had difficulty getting information in a timely manner when requested. The nursing documentation was found to be out of date, disorganised and in some cases not relevant to the current status of the resident.

The staffing levels were also of concern, with the report stating that inspectors were “gravely concerned that the staffing levels and skill-mix remained inadequate”.

The report also uncovered that a nurse on duty had previously worked 14 hours without a break. At other times, “there was no nurse on duty in the centre from 10.00 am to 2.00 pm”.

Residents

The report also described the condition of residents, noting that the atmosphere was “subdued” and that “staff appeared hurried with no time for conversation.” As well we this, the times at which residents rose varied:

Some residents were noted to be in bed very late in the morning, one resident was seen having his breakfast at the dinner table at 11.40 am, he was left at the table and remained there until his dinner was served at 12.30 pm.

Residents were also found to be “unkempt and their hair not brushed or combed,” with some wearing clothes that weren’t ironed and/or were dirty. In addition:

Residents’ finger nails were not cared for and required cleaning and trimming. Male residents were unshaved. There was a ‘bowel/shower’ book in use, this indicated that the majority of residents did not have a bath or shower in the previous month instead ‘sponge’ was recorded.

The unannounced inspection also found that fire training had not been completed, despite a previous assurance from the nursing home that it had.

When contacted by TheJournal.ie, the nursing home’s proprietor and director, Theresa O’Toole, would not respond to any questions.

The HIQA report is available in full here.

Read: Health watchdog visits Donegal nursing home after six deaths in two weeks >

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (15 Comments)

  • All inspections ought to be unannounced

    Reply
  • I volunteered there when I was around 16. It seemed very well run when I was there. It’s terribly sad for the residents that it went so badly down hill.

    Reply
  • It’s very sad when older peoples needs cannot be met, when dignity is abandoned and staffing levels are not sufficient to take proper care of them.

    Reply
    • Welcome to what Labour has signed us all up to, where an “investor” such as our glorious Min for Health, tries to draw profit from the care of our most vulnerable. Do a bit of research on company law and where directors / shareholders primary focus lies – I’ll give you a hint, it certainly isn’t in the protection of the customer! So excuse me if I amn’t bowled over by a Labour MEP claiming to care!

      Reply
  • Sub human conditions in a nursing home in Ireland? Well I never……..

    Reply
  • This story is shocking. These Homes cost a lot of money. This ranks as exploitation of the elderly in terms of deprivation and money. If ever there was an argument in favour of end of life wishes being granted legal authority ,then this is it. If the report is accurate , those responsible ought to be put in Stocks and then jail. What does the DOH say to that proposal?

    Reply
  • If the HSE were still in charge of nursing home inspections, the home would be open and the report kept secret.
    HIQA may not be perfect but it is a huge improvement on its predecessor.

    Reply
  • This highlights a massive and quite disturbing trend in Ireland. We treat our elderly absolutely appallingly. Bad treatment of the elderly doesn’t just exist in nursing homes. Take the medias treatment of them for example. A few months back a nursing home in Donegal has 7 occupants die due to the same virus in a matter of days and it barely made the mainstream news. The same week there was an outbreak of a virus in a hospital in Belfast (a different country) and it was headlining the six one news as well as on the front pages of many of the broadsheets. We all grow old, we all will be old one day but it seems in Ireland once you get of a pensionable age you are deemed no longer necessary and in many instances a drain on services. It’s actually disgusting!

    Reply
  • the owners should face jail time, I have just read the report and image not been washed for month, someone stand over you while you eat(intimidating), actually whip them as jail too good for them

    Reply
  • My mother was living there a few years ago and I visited it frequently and never found the staff or the environment to be as described or disorganised. We were always treated with detailed information on her well being so I find the closure sad but we can’t assume the conditions are as some comments imply. Her careers were appreciated and my mother who was well capable of complaining was appreciative of her treatment.

    Reply
  • I think its disgusting and a disgrace that this is happening to our elderly, holy God does anyone care for anyone any more, and i have no doubt what so ever this is not an isolated incident , we need the nuns back to run our nursing homes and for that matter hospitals, those matrons took no crap….

    Reply
  • Reading the comments here and on other related articles i decided to read the report into this nursing home to form an intelligent and well informed opinion and I must say I am shocked and a little puzzled. I went on to the HIQA website and read several reports. Firstly I read the report on this nursing home and whilst I except that in many respects it is damming I am left with a number of questions. Firstly all of the reports that I read contained findings concerning resident satisfaction, but it seems odd to me that this report does not contain any mention of residents satisfaction or dissatisfaction. If the residents families are happy with the care these residents have received as it would seem from this article surely it follows that the residents themselves must be at least in some way satisfied about the level of care that they have received. my point is, it seems strange to me that nearly every other report that I read mentions patient satisfaction in some way yet I find it curious that any mention of patient satisfaction is absent from this report and it almost begs the question did they disagree with the HIQA inspectors?

    Secondly I read about a Nursing Home in another part of the Country given an extended period of time to meet standards and I also read several other reports of nursing homes (a lot of which were published yesterday) that were given time to meet standards. In particular there was another home in (also in the west of the Country) that on face value (as we are taking the report into this Owenriff nursing Home) appears to have been in a far graver situation than this nursing home yet it has been given time to rectify matters. My question is why were these nursing homes not closed as this one but given time to rectify matters? I don’t pretend to be an expert but to me this seems to be a case of ‘one rule for one and a different for others’ why was this nursing home also not extended the same curtsey and allowed time to rectify matters?

    Thirdly, I read an article recently (I believe contained in a national newspaperr) about new Government legislation that mentioned the government had changed it’s regulations regarding nursing homes and that it was no longer necessary to have 24/7 nursing care. From the report into this nursing home it seems they were without a nurse for a matter of 4 hours. Maybe I’m missing something but not having a nurse for 4 hours does not seem to be a breech of new government regulations but to me from this report it seems like HIQA have conveniently ignored these regulations.

    I stated above that I am not in any way an expert but I do believe in forming informed opinions. Like most people when I first read about this I was incredibly shocked and dismayed but with just a little time and common sense and reading the reports into this nursing home and others I am left with more questions about fairness, procedures and equal treatment for all nursing homes and institutions by HIQA than I was when I first heard this story. I firmly believe that there is a need for a regulatory body in this area but based on what I have read in other reports and the differing treatment received by different facilities I am left wondering should someone be regulating the regulator?

    Reply
  • Hiqa has its place and it’s no harm for nursing homes to be under scrutiny but on saying that, paperwork seems to be paramount. If its not written down it didnt happen, is the maxim. Carers and nurses have been inundated with paperwork since the introduction of hiqa and it must be completed every hour of every day. As a result of this. Your “spare time” is taken up with this instead of chatting with the elderly which is just as important as any medication!! I work in a nursing home where they have a choice of showers/bath or wash, and all will shower once if not twice a week but we could have a client that doesn’t believe “in all that washing”. Under the rules of hiqa the client has a right to refuse .. A wash/medication/food etc your handed are tied, you cannot force people to do things but if they malnourished/unclean etc you are still at fault! Also hiqa have but so many demands on nursing homes regarding single rooms/ en suites etc that many of our nursing homes are running on a shoe string! Unfortunately, we seem to have forgotten the real reason people are in these homes, they cannot look afterthemselves. Most don’t care if they haven’t got an ensuite, they want to be cared for, fed and have company. They don’t care whether the paperwork is done or not. They would prefer you to sit and talk with them for ten minutes.

    Reply
  • these conditions will remain as long there is no properly trained staff ! and then im not talking about the CA’s but also the nurses ! you can’t expect a GN to be fully qualified for the care of our senior citizens, why not ? they need a different kind of care and then not only physical but mostly mental. most…..i say most of the time when something’s wrong straight away they look at the medical side but many time’s it’s psychological, being cooped up 24/7 while you were used to be outsite, not being able to go out whenever you want ! etc. this makes a person depressed ! no more independence, always having to ask and because of the cuts getting no for an answer because there isn’t enough staff to begin with.
    if you look at other country’s they have what you call VIG’s wich in short means CA’s and nurses trained solemly for the care of the elderly ! training takes place in a nursinghome/ revalidation centre etc. specialist training for 3 years about the whole person !………..when will ireland follow ??

    Reply

Add New Comment