TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

HIQA inspectors criticise nursing home part-owned by minister

An unannounced inspection in February found a number of areas in which previous recommendations were not met.

James Reilly personally owns a 25 per cent stake - though currently in blind trust - in the Greenhill Nursing Home in Carrick-on-Suir.
James Reilly personally owns a 25 per cent stake - though currently in blind trust - in the Greenhill Nursing Home in Carrick-on-Suir.
Image: Sam Boal/Photocall Ireland

A NURSING HOME in Co Tipperary which is part-owned by Dr James Reilly, the minister for health, has been criticised in a HIQA report after an unannounced inspection there earlier this year.

Greenhill Nursing Home in Carrick-on-Suir was inspected in February, to appraise its progress in implementing recommendations which had previously been identified during a planned inspection in November 2009.

The inspection report – which is available online, and was spotted by today’s Sunday Times – said that the inspection’s findings “did not support satisfactory implementation of the required improvements as outlined in the action plan” following the original 2009 visit.

Of the eight recommendations made in that original report, “one was satisfactorily implemented, two were substantially implemented but further action was required, five actions were not met and were reissued to the providers.”

The two inspectors also found that “significant improvements were required in two core areas fundamental to the quality and safety of care provided to residents”.

Drug delivery

Inspectors found particular problems with the facility’s administration of prescription drugs – including discrepancies in the records of the medication being prescribed to patients and the records of the drugs actually administered.

One resident went eight months without a prescribed medication being administered, the report said, while another’s prescription sheet was only amended via a Post-It note when a new medication was added to it.

Further, not all the medications which needed to be administered in a crust format were identified and prescribed as such.

In a supplement to the report, outlining the nursing home’s response to the follow-up inspections, the home agreed “to review the current medication management systems and practices and put in place suitable arrangements, appropriate procedures and practices and written policies” in order to ensure the appropriate administration of medicines.

Reilly owns a 25 per cent stake in the home in a personal capacity, and has listed this in the Dáil register of members’ interests every year since his first election as a TD in 2007.

The 2001 edition of the register notes that he has placed his ownership in blind trust since his appointment as Minister for Health, in line with recommendations from the Standards in Public Office Commission.

Similarly, the 2011 register showed that Reilly – who also owns a shopping centre, including a medical clinic, in Lusk – was no longer a practising GP, had transferred his own practice to another GP, and was seeking to remove his name from the medical register accordingly.

Reilly does not have a management capacity in the Greenhill home; HIQA records list Dr Dilip Jondhale and Dr Vasudha Jondhale as the registered service providers in that facility.

Read next:

Comments (35 Comments)

  • Not one single person here has mentioned the elephant in the room………… This is the ultimate in ‘conflict of interests’. Government Ministers should not be allowed to own a business that they can change and make legislation for, simply put it is corruption. Anyone who voted for Reilly just perpetuates this corruption. Minister for justice Alan Shatters position is the same, here we have a Justice Minister with a huge family law practice who profiteers out of peoples misery yet who can legislate to make the business even more profitable.

    Reply
    • Well so what you’re saying is that we can’t have Doctors as Health Minister or Lawyers as Justice Minister. They’re all bound to either have some conflicts themselves or have friends/colleagues who they may like to see benefit too.

      Reply
    • Hypocrisy of the commentators on here is astounding as usual. Most criticise our cabal of schoolteachers running government departments, saying experts should be running them. And then when there’s a Doctor running Health and a solicitor running Justice, they are criticsed for having a conflict on interest.

      Reply
  • Is this not an example of corrupt conflict of interest? How can he have private investments in a business he legislates on?

    Reply
  • And we have this man managing the health service and he can’t even run a nursing home he owns properly!

    Reply
  • Hungover Brendan Grace strikes again.

    Reply
  • When will this nursing home be closed after all Roscommon A&E was closed on Lies and HIQA never even went inside the Door and James Reilly gave false figures on the Fatality rate Liars is all this Government are

    Reply
    • For once I actually agree with you Bernadette!

      Except Roscommon was really closed to save money. That was the reason they gave at the start until everyone got mad with them so they made up the false fatality figures and pretended HIQA had recommended closure (both of which the govt later admitted were false).

      So that’s why Reilly’s nursing home won’t be closed. HIQA had nothing to do with Roscommon’s closure.

      Reply
    • Couldn’t agree more with you bernadette!

      Reply
    • Absolutely dead right Bernadette. They are liars and would do and say ANYTHING to get their own way.
      Reilly has a 25% interest in this Home , he does not manage it , but does he not go to meetings regarding his investment ? Who manages the managers ? Of course he has a say in how it is run and how much the budget is re staff, heat, food , etc etc…. What ? Does he think we came down with the rain today ?

      Reply
    • No, HIQA had absolutely nothing to do with the Roscommon A&E closure it was most definitely Kenny and Reilly just shaft Denis Naughton or why else did Kenny announce it on the day of Denis’s opening of his C.O.

      Reply
  • Wow! And this is the guy everyone believed with his ’5 Point Plan’ !!!! Then you give away your sovereignty because these clowns asked you to…fools

    Reply
  • @Alan Beirne,

    Just like F Fail, bertie aherne and Leas Cross! People, ask John Aherne received the contract for his nursing home? (EUR4million), Has businesses in his name, his wife’s name, sons etc. How did John Aherne receive planning permission for houses for family members and Leas Cross? Yet, other people that came from the same area, farmers sibblings couldn’t get planning on their own land? I better say “Allegedly”!

    Reply
  • I learned one thing today, I use that shopping centre in Lusk not any more.
    I never spend another penny in he place.
    I know Doctor death doesn’t need my money but he’s not getting it anyway.

    Reply
  • So much for private services being better than State services. Wonder how the plans to hand the health service over to private interests is going?

    Reply
  • This guy is useless and full of hot air. His biggest priority is to stop people enjoying a smoke in the park while out walking their dog. When that point was put to him on primetime all he kept saying was think of the children. His main ambition is to get his name in the history books like Michael Martin and not fix the HSE. Check out his mansion in today’s Sunday Independent page 5. He gets paid to live there. Unbelievable …

    Reply
  • In fairness he probably has bigger fish to fry. He has a stake in it, but probably isn’t the manager!

    Reply
    • mart_n 03/06/12 #

      He should grill his fish instead

      Reply
    • @Stadler Waldorf

      The fact that he has a ‘stake in it’ is all the more reason why he should be keeping an eye on it! He is earning money or his wife and children are earning money from the HSE/families of these OAP’s. The owner of Leas Cross received over EUR4million from bertie aherne and mary harney and look what happened there!

      Money grapper, just like the rest of them. They will still have their TD’s pension, their Ministerial penion and a huge bank account from all his other interests eg, nursing homes. The so called manager of Leas Cross, Graine Conway received a salary each month for doing what? and is probably still in the same type of work to this day. God help our aged. Thank God my parents have passed. Unfortunately my father’s passing was sooner than it should after spending 2 weeks in the hell hole Leas Cross.

      Minister Reilly needs to remember what he is, firstly he’s a father, he’s a son, he’s a doctor. Please Minister Reilly, remember where you came from!

      Reply
    • If it was our mum or dad in the home I think your view would change.

      Reply
    • Did anyone actually read the article? It says he has a ‘blind trust’ arrangement – a necessity on account of a potential conflict of interest. Therefore he is not entitled to interfere in the running of the business. He is essentially a silent partner. @Stadler I assume that is what you are getting at. For him to intervene would compromise his position – people would be saying that the minister is looking after his own. Damned if he does, damned if he doesn’t. The management of the home have a lot to answer for, it would seem.

      Reply
  • Greenhills is one of the better homes out there in fairness. Hiqa’s rules are very tight, most homes would be in breach of a few, it’s all about keeping up standards.

    Reply

Add New Comment