TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 16 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Report: Irish rate of young male suicide ‘among EU’s highest’

The cross-border Men’s Health Forum in Ireland also says self-harming is higher in males at some age grades.

Image: Young man photo via Shutterstock

IRELAND’S RATE of suicide among young males is among the highest in the European Union, a report on male suicide published today will declare.

The Young Men and Suicide Report, compiled by the cross-border Men’s Health Forum in Ireland, says that while the rate of male suicide across all age groups is relatively low by European norms, suicide rates among younger males is high.

It also found that suicide now ranks as a major cause of death among young males in both the Republic and Northern Ireland, and that the recent spike in suicide rates on either side of the border had clashed with both the economic downturn and an increase in unemployment.

It further found that though the issue of deliberate self-harm was more commonly associated with women, rates of deliberate self-harm are now higher in males at some age groups.

The report outlines 12 key recommendations, including the development and promotion of positive models of mental health aimed at young males, and challenging the ‘traditional masculine ideology’ which is seen as a cause of difficulty in encouraging men to seek help.

‘No quick fix’

“There can be no quick-fix solutions to tackling the very grave statistics on suicide in young men on the island of Ireland, but neither is there any place for inertia or ambivalence,” said Dr Noel Richardson, the lead author of the report.

There is both a public health and a moral requirement to act. There needs to be a concerted effort to engage more effectively, and in a more sustained way, with young men, and to plan services and programmes with young men in mind.

The report outlines evidence that early intervention in childhood, where men are taught not to attach a stigma to emotional expression, can help improve mental health at later stages of life.

However, there were also concerns that many people may perceive the issues faced by young men as trivial, when the issues causing distress to them are experienced as major problems for the young men themselves.

Junior health minister Kathleen Lynch, whose responsibilities include mental health, will tell the formal launch of the report that reducing suicide rates “requires a collective, concerted effort and, most importantly, a collaborative approach.”

Read: Samaritans’ SMS service reveals high levels of self-harm

Read next:

Comments (40 Comments)

  • Mike 23/01/13 #

    Way more men die by suicide than die on the roads every year, but you just never hear about it.

    Reply
    • tom 23/01/13 #

      Deliberate targeting and penalising yound male drivers can’t have helped.
      High unemployment lack of social out lets and isolation have to be contributing factors. Hopefully the EU ruling on insurance equality will in some small way help.

      Reply
    • @ Tom “Hopefully the EU ruling on insurance equality will in some small way help” All this is going to acomplish is the raising of Female insurance. All this government can come up with to help anything is raise or increase revenue generating taxes and charges on everything. When they can dream up a Self Harm tax they will pat themselves on the back, and think they’ve solved it.

      Reply
    • tom 23/01/13 #

      Most young guys strive to have a car and what the insurance cartel done was rip off and penalise young male drivers with stats that didnt reflect claims. Saying female insurance has to go up now isn’t a good reason to revert back to unfairly penalising young male drivers. I paided for both my son and daughters insurance so I’m seeing the impact at both sides but hopefully over all the insurance will be less.

      Its this type of discrimination along with media and socity at large that subjects young males to a feeling that they are of lesser value especially if they are unemployed.

      Reply
  • Kathleen Lynch…. Instead of telling us something we already know…. How about telling what was done in the past to battle suicide…. Tell us what worked and didn’t work… And tell us which strategies you’re going to use to tackle this issue. Death by suicide and the mortality rate has always been high in Ireland.

    Instead of giving us sound bites… Give us something concrete. Give us something we can support. Give us something that will save our sons, brothers and young fathers.

    Reply
    • Leonie 23/01/13 #

      I agree Marlon,
      I have personally met with Kathleen Lynch on this very subject (May 2012). Despite 2 medical experts telling her that prescription drugs are causing suicide, she has done nothing. http://leoniefennell.wordpress.com/2012/05/03/the-medical-experts-meet-in-leinster-house/
      Useless Government, all talk and couldn’t care less.
      Leonie

      Reply
    • Leonie…

      This is a very sad situation. I truly have bope we tbe people not our government will find a solution to this and other issues. It is clear that our politicians and government officials can’t think themselves out of bag.

      Furthermore, I would like to put forward. If our government was run more like a business. Where the bottom line translated to results. Where yearly audits where completed and published to the share holder (us the people). Where KPIs is used to measure success…. Then we would see a clear line of action.

      A business’s success is related to having the right people in place to tbe job. It is clear that we haven’t had the right people in place to the job of running this country and tackling serious issues as suicide for very very long time.

      Reply
    • Gritty and real ! What do you say Kathleen ?

      Reply
    • @leonie. yes those prescription drugs have alot to answer for.

      Reply
  • Of course Ireland is steeped in stigma. Anything outside our so called norm has stigma attached . My heart goes out to the younger generation. Things were tough in my generation but tough in a different way . It may look like the youth today have it easier than we had but they have much more to deal with . I don’t believe recession and unemployment is the cause but of course could be the trigger to the underlying pain . I believe there should be some subject added to the education system to encourage thought and expression from a young age . A forum to discuss “what’s it all about” .

    Reply
  • Unfortunatly this is not news to anyone. Life is very tough for so many now, especially the young who can’t get jobs. I know I will get slated for bringing politics into it but its another indictment of FF and what they did to our country.

    Reply
  • Mjhint 23/01/13 #

    Stephen I disagree.Over the last few months I have being watching media reports about suicide including the abortion debate & it sickens me when I see it being batted about & trivialised. Suicide is one of the biggest social issues in this country & although we are getting better at it we dont fully understand its impact. I am proud when I see the abortion debate being passionately debated but suicide is a far bigger issue & a growing problem that affects men & women with no honest debate.Its not just about services either its our attitude to it. Its a very frightening subject that we must all do more to understand including myself. We have become a society of lonely frightened people. People are living in fear & no one trusts one another. I do not have answers for any of this but most people in the country have been or will be affected by suicide. That is a frightening prospect & I have 4 children myself & that scares me. Suicide is more than just about bullying or even mental health.Its about isolation & hopelessness & a feeling of disconnection. We all not just ff have a reponsibility in it or we will all be getting that phone or that shock of finding love ones in distress in the future.

    Reply
  • Fred… I agree… However, I would like to add… Ireland has a culture where people, the system and society tells don’t encourage young people during their formative years. You are more likely to hear discouragement than encouragement.

    There is such a weight that hoovers over us… The weight is begrudgery. Begrudgery does not permit positive reinforcement. And I believe it is tbis cultural phenomenon that adds to the unsuccessful pursuit of so many things I Ireland.

    I am very fortunate in that I have always had a sunny disposition. This really aids me in my day-to-day… Where people seldom smile or laugh. Where a bubbly personality is looked on as being odd.

    So a great cultural strategy within the school system is to add the philosophy. .. Yes you can! And… There is no limit to how high you can fly

    Reply
  • Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem. There is nowhere near enough being done to tackle this problem on every level. SOSAD are amazing and dont get a fraction of the support or credit they deserve

    Reply
    • “Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.” I’m afraid that a simplistic view taken by people who can’t or don’t want to understand.
      The problem is that many young men take their own lives because they see it as a “……..permanent solution to a PERMANENT problem. That is, no prospect of employment, the social stigma and pressures of having no meaning in life because of no money or work and exacerbated by maybe being the only one in their peer group in that situation.
      The Government needs to tackle this with at least the same vigour as they have taken on drink driving. Then again, would Ibe too cynical in stating that when young people take their own lives, its one less on the live register.
      But then again, they would never think like that!………….or would they?

      Reply
    • That’s exactly how they think Gerry, We are nothing but numbers and all they care about is balancing their books! They don’t give a phuck about any of us or our families! Listen to how they speak to us, they’ve nothing but contempt for us, we’re like the piece of sh!t on the bottom of their shoes.

      Reply
    • The government dehumanizes the “bottom of the barrel”, but they rely on it for their livelihoods. We may be just numbers to them, but numbers can be powerful when they’re rocking the boat.

      Reply
  • Why why why can something not be done to help these peple

    Reply
  • There are always reasons for living, once we get through a rough patch. But the question is do people want to listen when you are going through a rough patch? It is possible to listen to someone, without judgement, and without taking on their problems. Occasionally or from time to time.

    I can no longer take “anti-depressants”/SSRIs. I developed symptoms of Bipolar disorder while on an “anti-depressant” for panic attacks (4.5 years ago) and I still have this “Substance-induced Bipolar disorder” today. SSRIs come with risks eg increased risk of suicide and/or violence in some people (according to people like Psychiatrist Dr Peter Breggin in New York and Professor David Healy in Wales. http://www.breggin.com/31-49.pdf and www.http://davidhealy.org/ )

    There are alternatives to boost a persons mood – talk therapy, keeping a journal, good nutrition, reducing caffeine/sugar/alcohol/tobacco, exercise, good sleep hygiene, having a good support network, yoga, meditation, proper breathing, keeping hydrated, Mary Ellen Copeland’s WRAP programme etc I realise that overdoing things is not good. Stress management is important.

    The “chemical imbalance” theory has never been proven. From what I read, most of our serotonin is produced in the gut. While some tranquilizers can help for a few days in a crisis, there is no pill that will cure Life.

    [Never stop or change medication without consulting a good doctor, due to the dangers of withdrawal]

    Reply
  • The Irish mental health environment created by the endless negative whinging or violent media, broadcasters and soaps must be partly to blame

    Reply
  • Serious problem too long ignored, will raise lots of awkward questions if not simplified into the “young men are idiots” typical nonsense.

    Erosion of role models, undermining at every turn of clear advantages, focus on female performance and manipulation of statistics. (better leaving result for girls, but better university grades for men always ignored) Discrimination, and patronisation, also the feminization of education at primary and secondary etc etc…..

    Finally the “among” the highest in europe is a meaningless sentence, all countries in europe are “among” the highest”.

    Reply
    • Meh 23/01/13 #

      Absolutely, suicide is predominantly a male issue, there will be lots of comments about stereotypical mental health issues affecting men, but they miss the point. The narrative is always that there must have been something fundamentally wrong with someone who took an extreme measure in the face of hopelessness and it’s almost along the lines of victim blaming.

      Men issues are ignored in general, their role in society is never acknowledged unless it has been framed from a feminist friendly perspective, being a man in today’s society is a minefield especially in relation to family law.
      The State encouraged destruction of a basic collective unit of society – the family, and the huge increase in children growing up without the role models that are crucial to a childs development further undermines and makes men invisible.
      I attended recently a conference on Homelessness in Ireland where the main speaker who was a woman preceded to tell the attendees that Homelessness in Ireland is predominantly women’s issue and more resources are needed to combat this and that the recession affects more women than men. The next slide in her presentation showed that roughly 25% of homeless people are women. However as the talk went on it dawned on me that there was no mention of the other glaring 75% of the picture.
      It speaks for itself.

      Male suicide 4 times higher
      Secondary School drop out rates – Twice the number of boys are earlyschool leavers
      Homelessness – 75%
      Family Law courts – biased against fathers
      Domestic Violence against men – framed as a non issue when it’s as huge and under-reported
      Alcohol/Drug abuse deaths – 66% of those who died were men, with the 25- to 44-year age group having the highest number of fatalities.

      Reply
  • “Challenging the ?traditional masculine ideology’” is likely a double edged sword that could have both positive and negative consequences.

    This ideology can be a disincentive, putting most men off the thought of self abuse. Many men could feel like it’s an “unmanly” thing to do, and therefore could be less likely to do it.

    If a man is self inflicting and if that man does not report it, it is due to the depression itself and the feeling of loneliness and hopelessness that it brings, as opposed to his fear of being brandished “unmanly”.

    Traditional masculinity is flawed, but it does have traits that deter self abuse.

    Reply
  • Hi guys – trying to comprehend this paragraph

    “However, there were also concerns that many people may perceive the issues faced by young men as trivial, when the issues causing distress to them are experienced as major problems for the young men themselves.”

    Am I right in paraphrasing this as:

    “There were concerns in the report that issues faced by young men are considered trivial by many, despite the fact that young men consider the issues that they face to be major problems”.

    Reply
  • No mjhint you missed the point. Bank bondholders etc priority. Suicide is and should be priority but the reality is when you turn on rte news what will u hear. Aib anglo bank of ireland ecb mr kenny noonan et all. Brussels frankfurt merkel.

    Reply
    • Conor 23/01/13 #

      Stop linking in a government rant in an article about suicide.

      Reply
    • Sadly mental health disabilliy elderly people sick children are not top priority for our goverment thats my point.

      Reply
    • Mjhint 23/01/13 #

      Again Lee you fail the test. You not rte have brought the bondholders & all that bagage to this thread. You have nothing to say about suicide. The news on rte have had stories about it & the journal is great at discussing it. Im looking to you to put your back to the wheel. Our society must change its attitude to suicide. We must all take responsibilty & that includes you. I know as do most others commenting on the journal about government shortcomings however that has nothing to do with our attitude to suicide. They wont/cant change but we have to. Our children are dying before we are & for me thats not natural.

      Reply
    • Jesus Christ. All you’re doing is ranting off a populist line of claptrap which has nothing, NOTHING, to do with the topic at hand. Please, don’t drag another important topic into some old wheeze about “teh bondholderz” or the EU.

      Reply
    • Julie 23/01/13 #

      I have lost 3 friends to suicide all in one month, my younger brother who is 17 has lost two a young girl and a young boy, I live in a small town and there was never this amount of suicide , this government has failed my generation, they have left us with no jobs no hope they are crippling our families and making it hard for them to live, so you have these young people stuck living at home no hope of a job and watching there parents struggle, no one knows how hard that is until you are in that situation ! It is the governments fault they have destroyed Ireland for my generation, I’m lucky I have my degree I can leave and start my life somewhere Else. The younger generation can see that this is not over it only getting worse and they are made to feel crap because they have to sign on! FF have destroyed this country for my generation and FG just finishing off the work FF were doing ! What I think is a joke is that there was no big issue around suicide until it was one of their own that it tragically happened to, they look afte each other and don’t care about us. I have had enough !

      Reply
  • Sad state of our country folks, wheres the mast protest over this. Seems it not trendy enough

    Reply
  • We can not put everything on to polticans, regardless of which party they belong to. As a nation, as a community, as a family member, we should all be reaching out more and giving some time and understanding to people around us who are struggling. Our time is the most important thing we can give anyone, it’s not about having answers or solutions to someones problems, but giving them a listening friendly could be enough to encourage them to talk about what is going on for them

    Reply
  • The suicide crisis is being dealt with. The bondholders are priority though.

    Reply
    • Mjhint 23/01/13 #

      Again Lee I point to the problem of trivialising suicide. Suicide is a far bigger issue than bondholders & you failed the test. If you have some input about suicide it would welcome.

      Reply

Add New Comment