TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 15 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Column: I train to stay physically healthy – I should treat my mental health no differently

When I tell people I have a physical trainer, they think I must be stronger and fitter as a result of it – yet there is a stigma attached to attending a counsellor or psychologist, writes Tom Murphy.

Tom Murphy

National Employment Week (NEW), a forum focusing on major social and economic issues is currently taking place. On NEW’s Mental Health Day, businessman Tom Murphy speaks out about the double-standards and stigma connected to mental and physical well-being.

WOULD YOU LIKE a fight?

It’s a perfectly reasonable question. I’m enquiring if you would like to engage in combat. Fisticuffs. Queensbury rules sir! But wait, first I should tell you I train with a professional Muay Thai kick-boxer. A man who stands nearly 6 foot tall, weighs 16 stone of pure muscle and who has fought in some of the biggest stadiums in Thailand. We’ve been training privately twice a week for years now.

So, would you like a fight? No? Ok, I understand. That information changes things I guess. Knowing your opponent trains in a combat sport would make most rational people think twice about getting in a ring. Not that I’m anything to write home about in the kick-boxing field but, still, anyone who trains regularly has to be better at it than the average Joe, right? Fitter at the very least!

I want to stay healthy

Now, I don’t train because I’m physically sick or ill. I train when I’m healthy because I want to stay healthy. I go to a trainer because it’s always easier to have outside help. A personal trainer helps motivate you and forces you to focus. They see the things you wouldn’t see yourself. When I’m training we work on the areas I’m not good at, areas I might otherwise quietly ignore.

When I don’t get this sort of exercise my physical well-being suffers. I get fat, lazy and sluggish. If I let that go to the extreme I risk all sorts of unpleasant consequences like heart disease etc. When I go training regularly I see improvement. I feel better. I’m stronger fitter and less tired.

I also see a counsellor regularly. I work on training my thinking to be rigorous and strong. Just like in physical training, we work on areas that need it and I do it not because I’m sick now, but because I want to stay healthy in the future and reap the benefits of good mental health.

Just like my boxing coach, my counsellor sees things from the outside that need work and I can access his expertise to improve. He shows me exercises and routines that will help me improve and together we can see the benefits over time.

Stigma

In many ways, these are similar activities. If I stop counselling I risk descending into patterns of thinking which are not positive and not good for me. Like physical exercise if I neglect it to the extreme I risk much more serious consequences.

My point to all of this is that when I tell people I have a physical trainer, they think I must be stronger and fitter as a result of it. But there is a stigma attached to attending a counsellor or psychologist. Somehow the implication is that you must be mentally weaker when in fact, the reverse is much more likely.

To me this is a harmful nonsense which stops our progression both as a nation and as individuals. It’s the seed of a stigma that needs to be challenged head on. We will quite happily tell someone we’re “dying with flu” but a touch of depression or low mood and its like the third secret of Fatima. That turns it from something which can be dealt with quite readily, into something much more dangerous.

If there is one message I would like people to take from the Mental Health Day of Employment Week it’s this: if someone tells you they are working on their mental well-being, don’t think they are mentally weak. If they told you they were training in a gym would you think they were physically weak?

A founder and director of Boards.ie and Adverts.ie , Tom is a successful entrepreneur. Winner of the Irish Internet Associations “Net Visionary” for social impact, he has been at the forefront of the internet in Ireland for 15 years.

Read next:

Comments (37 Comments)

  • Excellent article. I can shamefully say that I would have been guilty of associating counselling with mental weakness, while on the other hand associating training with physical strength and fitness. It has opened a new perspective on mental health for me and I hope it does the same for others. Well done!

    Reply
    • I think part of it is the view that a lot of people have of what counselling is (sitting on a couch complaining about your childhood.) I have a severe anxiety disorder and find going through coping methods with a counsellor to be really helpful – being active and conscientious about your health is always a good thing.

      Reply
  • Excellent piece!

    Reply
  • I know we’re pressed for resources in the education budget, but wouldn’t it be great to introduce some form of (good) mental health training into the secondary school curriculum. No idea how this could be achieved or funded. Just know we have suicide epidemic in this country, and maybe each student getting a regular slot with a Councillor might be a positive thing. not just in the most extreme cases of suicidal tendencies, but also for general well- being.

    Reply
  • Enjoyable read.I think that stigma is lessening now.A friend told my recently bout her going to a councellor and she expected my reaction to be?Well i dont know but i was not shocked.Who is anyone to judge?Gota mind ur head aswell..

    Reply
  • What a brilliant article

    Reply
  • That is a great article Tom and it makes a lot of sense. I have been off work with chronic depression for the past 18 months and outside of my closest circle of friends it is not spoken about or referred to when I meet people, in contrast, I broke my arm last week and everybody is only delighted to talk about it and enquire about the details of how it happened. I believe we need a targeted mental health campaign in the way there are campaigns healthy eating, fitness and road safety. Mental illness, depression, addictions and suicide are an endemic part of our society and need to be addressed in a supportive and empathetic manner. You make the very valid point also of the need to look after one’s mental health on an ongoing basis and again there needs to be education and raising of awareness around this. While I think it is great that you see a counsellor on a regular basis to maintain mental health, unfortunately many people could not afford this which is why government interventions and strategies are needed in my opinion. Just as a point of information for anyone who is on here and needing some health there is a great organisation called M

    Reply
  • A fantastic read, it would spur on many people who know they need support with their mental health yet think of the reaction of others and postpone seeking support. I love your comparison to sport. Such a refreshing read, thank you

    Reply
  • There is a great organisation called MyMind.org which offers affordable supports in Dublin and Cork and also online.

    Reply
  • Shame the word ‘stigma’ is mentioned too many times above.. The same old stupid conversation about mental health and how it’s being treated in current times. The word ‘weak’ sneaks across here too.. I am suffering for many yrs now & possibly at my worst as I type today.. Biggest problem is yes there may be help,u can take the pills but it never ever will be cured.. it comes with a hefty price I sadly cannot afford..and some of the comments ….. Don’t bother.. Unless u suffer please don’t pass judgement as u have NO IDEA!!!!

    Reply
  • Excellent piece Tom. I think your approach is a smart one and it makes complete sense to tend to both the health of the body and mind. Common nonsense has looked unkindly on mental health (despite the high rates), it is good to see a rational approach being adopted and discussed.

    Reply
  • Anders 28/02/13 #

    Very nice piece indeed, we quickly need to unlabel all mental health issues and start open and informative discussions on this,

    Reply
  • Excellent article.

    Reply
  • The writer is a successful businessman who can afford a personal trainer and a counsellor. That he makes an analogy between the two shows that the counselling he receives is at the lifecoach rather than the psychotherapy end of the spectrum.
    It’s nice to be well-off enough to employ a personal trainer and I’m sure it’s money well-spent. But would thejournal publish an article saying we should all have a personal trainer if we want to stay in shape? No, it’s common sense that while a personal trainer is a nice thing to have, it’s totally possible to keep fit without one.
    Likewise talking to friends, famiily and colleagues is good for us. Talking to a counsellor is nice, and you get to talk about yourself all the time, but again it’s a luxury. No one should feel their health is in any way at risk because they can’t get to/don’t want to see a counsellor.
    Some people may need counselling from a clinical psychologist for an actual mental health problem. But this is more analogous to a physiotherapist than to a personal trainer.

    Reply
  • Such a great read! well done Tom!

    Reply
  • Tom, thank you for your article. I don’t want to pour cold water over it, because I agree with every word. And you seem like an honourable and kind man. However I wish to draw to your attention to the reaction I encountered on your forum, boards.ie, when I mentioned an affair currently in the news in which a pertinent individual’s company was involved (because there are legal matters in progress I am phrasing myself VERY carefully) on the “(person on at 11am on Today FM) on Sunday” thread in the radio forum.

    Some posters asked me more questions about it, combatively enough, and I responded. But I was very swiftly and patronisingly slapped down by a moderator and told I was engaged in “creative writing”. The moderator had obviously looked up my profile and used my experience of writing fiction as a method to discredit me. It was as good as calling me a fantasist.

    I understand that there might have been libel concerns since Irish libel law allows much latitude for making legal threats. But this was never brought up as a reason to censor every single word I wrote. Instead they accused me of being “off-topic” – improbably, since I was writing about the same individual as in the title thread. And the “creative writing” insult I’ve mentioned already. Had it ever been truthfully admitted that the real concern was fear and libel, rather than patronising me and talking down to me, I think I would not have made this comment today.

    They have denied and denied that they are scared of libel but I as an individual raising concerns about mental health issues – and working hard to maintain good mental health – felt slapped down, denied and suppressed. In fact the interaction I experienced on boards.ie was one of the more repellent experiences I encountered during 2012 when I was speaking about this issue.

    I want to make it clear that this is not some personal hurt I am writing about. I am quite capable of living my daily life without the approval of the goodly personages on your forum, and I am personally and professionally happy. But tactics such as these which seek to discredit the speaker are responsible for suppressing the very conversation you say you want to have. And it is an attack on somebody who cannot defend themselves.

    I am sincere, serious and worried about this, please believe me. I think you need to make it clear what your libel rules will and will not allow with regards to an honest discussion about mental health.

    Thank you Tom if you have read this far and I wish you well.

    Reply
    • Just to clarify my last comment – the matter in question was very clearly and glaringly an issue concerning mental health. It wasn’t some random item on the news with me going “waaaaah, somebody was MEEEEEN to me!”

      Reply
  • Great Article Tom,
    What you say is so true……
    Why should working on your mental health be percieved as a sign of weakness?
    it looks like tackling the issue of stigma surrounding mental health and illness is going to be done the same way you’d eat an elephant, one bite at a time………one conversation at a time.

    My bite is that I’m holding a http://www.seechange.ie – ‘Tackling Mental Health Stigma’ Meetup in the Stillorgan Park Hotel, on April 11, 7.30 – 9pm.
    See http://www.meetup.com/Stop-the-Stigma-of-Mental-Illness-Dublin/events/104505842/

    It’s a forum for people to meet & plan some stigma tackling events.
    Maybe distributing the Seechange wristbands and literature, maybe a game of soccer in Blackrock Park, Maybe a walk on Sandymount strand.

    Whatever we do, we’ll talk, raise awareness, and tackle stigma.

    Thanks again for speaking today & writing this article.

    We’re all in this together,

    Regards,

    Joe McCarthy –

    PS: I’m the guy from Cork I asked the first question about appropriate language & mental health this morning.

    Reply
  • What a great article fair play to Tom. He wrote in very honest and direct manner. A great example of how we should ideally look at our mental health. We need to keep up our physical and mental health – to really be fit for life. Talking to someone if you are feeling low is always a great exercise, whether it be a friend, family member or qualified mental health professional.
    http://www.helplink.ie

    Reply
  • Assumptions: the things you don’t know you’re making.

    There’s abundant empirical evidence that physical exercise improves physical health (and mental health, come to that) in both physically healthy and physically unhealthy people. There’s some empirical evidence that counselling helps improve the mental health of certain types of mentally unhealthy people.

    Is there any empirical evidence that counselling helps improve the mental health of people who are already mentally healthy?

    If not, then the “stigma” issue is moot.

    Reply
    • There’s plenty of evidence. Check out the whole field of Positive Psychology and the work of Seligman. Google “Authentic Happiness” to find out more, or go to internationaljournalofwellbeing.org to read an open-access journal on the subject.

      Reply
    • censored 02/03/13 #

      Ok, I want to increase my mental powers. Any recommendations? I’d like to start with telekinesis and move on to telepathy.

      Reply
  • Great piece and very true to form. Last week a person told me they were attending a Counselor and then they swore me to secrecy.

    Reply
  • excellent article, well put tom

    “Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won’t come in”

    Reply
  • Surly ‘training your brain’ would involve doing advanced maths or trying to decipher a medieval poem. People hear councilor and they think that you’re in an office talking about your feelings.

    Reply
  • Learn Chess, make it the national “game”

    Reply
  • It is almost impossible to count the number of times the word “I” is used in this article.

    Reply

Add New Comment