#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 17°C Thursday 19 May 2022
Advertisement

Elizabeth Holmes: Silicon Valley's fallen star

Blood-testing start-up CEO Elizabeth Holmes was found guilty of defrauding investors.

Holmes speaking at the Wall Street Journal Digital Live conference in California, October  2015.
Holmes speaking at the Wall Street Journal Digital Live conference in California, October 2015.
Image: Alamy Stock Photo

ELIZABETH HOLMES’ STARTUP Theranos made her a multi-billionaire hailed as the next US tech visionary by age 30, but it all evaporated in a flash of lawsuits, ignominy and, finally, criminal charges.

The rise and fall of Holmes, who today was convicted of defrauding investors of her biotech startup, is a heavily-chronicled saga that prompted a hard look at her methods but also the unseemly aspects of startup life.

In many ways, Holmes fit the image of a Silicon Valley entrepreneur, from her dark-coloured turtleneck sweaters that evoked tech legend and Apple founder Steve Jobs to her dropping out of California’s elite Stanford University.

But much like in her trial, the fundamental question has been whether she was a true visionary who simply failed, as she claimed on the stand, or a skilled self-promoter who took advantage of a credulous context to commit fraud.

Her story begins in the US capital Washington, with her birth to a Congressional staffer mother and a father whose online biography says he was once an executive at Enron – an energy company that collapsed in a massive fraud scandal.

She won admission to Stanford, and there began work on cutting-edge biomedical initiatives, founding in 2003 what would become Theranos when she was just 19.

Part of Holmes’s ability to convince her backers was her apparent deep personal commitment – she applied for her first patent while still in college and after dropping out, convinced her parents to let her use her tuition savings to build the company.

‘Youngest woman self-made billionaire’

By the end of 2010 she had raised a whopping $92 million in venture capital for Theranos, which she pledged was developing machines that could run a gamut of diagnostic tests on a few drops of blood.

Over the next couple of years, she assembled what one news report called the “most illustrious board in US corporate history”, including former secretaries of state Henry Kissinger and George Shultz as well ex-Pentagon chief Jim Mattis.

“Sharp, articulate, committed. I was impressed by her. That didn’t take the place of having the device prove itself,” said Mattis in a surprise appearance on the stand.

Theranos hype kicked up another gear in 2014 and in the span of just over a year, a turtleneck-wearing Holmes appeared on the covers of Fortune, Forbes, Inc. and T: The New York Times Style Magazine.

ceo-of-theranos-elizabeth-holmes-executive-chairman-alibaba-group-jack-ma-and-former-united-states-president-bill-clinton-wait-to-speak-on-stage-about-the-future-of-equality-and-opportunity-at-the-cl Holmes, Executive Chairman Alibaba Group Jack Ma and former United States President Bill Clinton wait to speak on stage about the future of equality and opportunity at the Clinton Global Initiative in 2015. Source: Alamy Stock Photo

newark-calif-usa-23rd-july-2015-vice-president-joe-biden-right-speaks-as-elizabeth-holmes-founder-and-ceo-of-theranos-left-listens-during-a-visit-to-theranos-manufacturing-in-newark-calif Then-Vice President Joe Biden pictured in 2015 during a visit to Theranos manufacturing in Newark, Calif. Source: Alamy Stock Photo

Forbes gave her a $4.5 billion net worth in 2014, which was based on her half ownership of Theranos, and noted: “Youngest woman on Forbes 400; Youngest woman self-made billionaire.”

This glowing coverage had an impact on Theranos investors like venture capitalist Chris Lucas who told Holmes’s trial the Fortune article made him “proud we were involved, very proud of Elizabeth.”

But there were some things that didn’t end up in those glowing reports that gushed with statements like “Steve Jobs had massive ambition, but Holmes’s is arguably larger.”

Silicon Valley sexism?

For one, she personally put the logos of pharma giants Pfizer and Schering-Plough onto Theranos reports hailing its own blood-testing technology, which were then shared with investors.

That was done without the companies’ permission and was a key piece of the prosecution’s argument that she deliberately tried to inflate Theranos’s credibility in order to win over backers.

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support us now

She also kept secret the machines’ failings and the fact that once Theranos began to do diagnostics on real patients, some of the tests were done using the same equipment sold to standard labs.

Ultimately though, it was a series of Wall Street Journal reports starting in 2015 — which Holmes tried to kill by appealing to the paper’s owner and Theranos investor Rupert Murdoch — that set the company’s collapse in motion.

theranos-founder-elizabeth-holmes-arrives-with-her-partner-billy-evans-as-the-jury-continues-to-deliberate-in-her-fraud-trial-at-federal-court-in-san-jose-california-u-s-december-23-2021-reuter Holmes arriving at her fraud trial at federal court in San Jose, California with her partner Billy Evans Source: Alamy Stock Photo

Holmes’s case also raised questions about why she was prosecuted, but not other tech CEOs who engaged in the “fake it until you make it” Silicon Valley method or other bad behaviour.

Ellen Pao, the former CEO of Reddit and critic of tech industry discrimination, argued in a New York Times opinion piece that sexism bears some blame.

She noted that WeWork’s Adam Neumann and Uber co-founder Travis Kalanick raised billions with hype, while there have been allegations of racism and sexism at Tesla and misleading claims about vaping from Juul’s leaders.

Holmes “should be held accountable for her actions as chief executive of Theranos,” Pao wrote.

But “it can be sexist to hold her accountable for alleged serious wrongdoing and not hold an array of men accountable for reports of wrongdoing or bad judgement,” she added.

© AFP 2022

About the author:

AFP

Read next:

COMMENTS (17)

This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
write a comment

    Leave a commentcancel