TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 6 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

One year after #Aras11, where are the failed presidential candidates now?

One wrote a book, one went on tour, one went back up the North and one went to Strasbourg. Here’s what Seán, Martin, Gay, David, Dana and Mary did next.

Image: Leon Farrell/Photocall Ireland

TODAY MARKS A year since the presidential election that followed a turbulent and bruising campaign, the likes of which had never been seen before in Ireland’s brief experience of presidential politics.

Seven candidates battled it out in the ‘Race for the Áras’ with the winner far from certain going into the final week before the game-changing RTÉ Frontline debate and the infamous ‘tweegate’ changed the course of the election and swung the result in the favour of the current incumbent Michael D Higgins.

Up until that TV debate polls indicated that it was independent Seán Gallagher who was on course to succeed Mary McAleese in the Áras after a strong campaign in which jobs and the creation of them appeared to be his main message. But along the way and ultimately to his downfall Gallagher had to deal with questions about his business interests and Fianna Fáil connections.

It was no different for the other candidates from Mary Davis and her State boards, Martin McGuinness and his IRA past, Gay Mitchell and his controversial remarks on suicide and views on abortion, David Norris and his views on paedophilia and Dana and the controversial allegations surrounding her family.

One year later the candidates are reluctant to go over old ground. We asked all six of the failed candidates for an interview but either received no response or we were told they were not interested in speaking to us. Nonetheless we’ve been looking at what they’ve been doing since last year.

4/10/2011 Presidential Elections Campaigns

In the case of Seán Gallagher – who picked up 28.5 per cent or nearly 505,000 first preference votes – he was travelling in the United States when contacted by TheJournal.ie and asked that we correspond via email. Further correspondence however did not yield any interview.

The former Dragon’ Den star did speak to RTÉ’s Gay Byrne recently in which he didn’t rule out another presidential bid in 2018 and spoke about how he retreated to a monastery in Sligo in the wake of the election: “We meditated, prayed and went for walks,” he said of his experience there.

He said that he was more focussed now on beginning a family with his wife Trish expecting their first baby in March.

“I had a wonderful experience,” Gallagher said of his insurgent campaign. “I met some of the most amazing people. Two-thousand, five hundred people joined my campaign and campaigned every night for me.”

Since then Gallagher has been touting himself as ‘speaker, trainer and entrepreneur’ with his website offering him up as a speaker on issues such as ‘Leadership’, ‘Personal Growth’ and ‘Business Development’. Of his presidential campaign, his website notes: “While ultimately coming second, he is credited with having run one of the most positive, dynamic, innovative and effective campaigns in Irish political history.”

Gallagher also writes for the Sunday Independent business section where he talks about meeting small Irish businesses that are enjoying success.

8/7/2009 Sinn Fein meet Irish Government

For third-placed Martin McGuinness – who picked up 13.7 per cent or just over 243,000 votes – it was back to the grind of being the Deputy First Minister of Northern Ireland following his election defeat. He declared himself “over the moon” with the support he had received through a turbulent campaign.

We asked McGuinness for an interview but our request was referred to the Stormont press office and we did not hear back. Since returning to Belfast the Sinn Féin MLA has been dealing with domestic matters including the recent and controversial opening of a private abortion clinic – which led to his restatement of his party’s opposition to the liberalisation of abortion laws in the North.

More broadly, McGuinness must deal with tensions between the parties in the power-sharing administration in the North, most recently over wide-ranging welfare reforms and claims by the DUP leader and McGuinness’ more senior partner in the executive, Peter Robinson, that Sinn Féin was operating in fear of the SDLP over areas like welfare and pension reforms and parades.

Oh, and McGuinness has also had the small matter of meeting Queen Elizabeth II and shaking her hand – a historic moment in Anglo-Irish relations.

19/10/2011. Presidential Campaigns

Fine Gael’s candidate Gay Mitchell – who picked up 6.4 per cent of the vote or just over 113,000 votes – also returned to the job he had before the presidential race as a member of the European Parliament for Dublin. It followed a hugely disappointing campaign for him and the party with one insider claiming “there was no craic with Gay” on the campaign trail, though this was later denied.

Mitchell also declined an interview request and has remained largely silent on his own views of how the campaign went, instead keeping himself busy in his parliamentary role in Strasbourg where he earns over €90,000 a year.

Though he declined an interview with us we have been taking a look at the questions he’s been putting forward in the European Parliament including one about the airplay of local and national music on national radio stations, and standardising the days on which Mother’s Day and Father’s Day are celebrated in Europe.

11/10/2012 David Norris A Kick Against the Pricks

Fifth-placed David Norris – who picked up 6.2 per cent and over 109,000 votes – was another to return to the day job, that being the Seanad where he has served for the last 25 years. His campaign was, as you may remember, a turbulent one which he exited before re-entering, a move which landed him in heavy debt.

He also declined an interview with us having decided instead to let his recently published book – A Kick Against the Pricks – “tell the tale” of the campaign and his life.

In that books he criticises the an unnamed journalist who he said had falsely claimed a letter of clemency he wrote for his former partner was about be published. The over-reaction of his staff to revelations about Ezra Nawi, the politicians who had supported his initial bid and then withdrew this support as well as the journalist Helen Lucy Burke are also criticised.

Since returning to the Seanad, Norris has taken issue with TV3′s Tallafornia and media regulation in Ireland.

4/10/2011 Presidential Elections Campaigns

Dana Rosemary Scallon surprised people be entering the race just before the deadline for nominations and came second last with 2.9 per cent of the vote or just over 51,000 first preference ballots. Her campaign was perhaps the most turbulent of all as she used one debate to read a statement regarding allegations about some family members.

She also declined an interview request, citing legal reasons when contacted by TheJournal.ie about doing an in-depth interview about her campaign. As part of her current role in  The Best of Eurovision Tour – a show involving some of Ireland’s Eurovision winners including Dana herself, Johnny Logan, Linda Martin and Charlie McGettigan – she did speak to Newstalk this week.

When asked by George Hook to reflect on her failed presidential bid, she said: “Generally it would be considered one of the roughest campaigns that Ireland has had for almost all of those who took part, a kind of a move towards an American style, very much attacking, very much on a personal level.”

Scallon said she did not regret running because “you have to stand up for what you believe is right” and also raised questions about voting Yes in the upcoming children’s referendum. Asked if she would run again she said she hoped not because of the “toll” it took.

“I have never stood up or put my name forward because I wanted a seat or a position, I always stood for it because I felt I had to speak out,” she said.

4/10/2011. Mary Davis Presidential Campaigns

Last but not least, the independent candidate Mary Davis – who got 2.7 per cent of the vote or just over 48,500 seats – has returned to her role as regional president and managing director of the Special Olympics Europe-Eurasia office where she earns about €165,000 annually. The role involves overseeing the growth of the Special Olympics across the nearly 60 countries that participate. She also continues to be the chair of Special Olympics Ireland.

We asked Davis for an interview but she has, according to a spokesperson, been travelling extensively recently and was not keen to go back over her disappointing campaign in which she spent over €400,000 – the second highest amount behind Gay Mitchell. As well as her Special Olympics work, the former candidate continues to enjoy running and mountain climbing, according to her spokesperson.

(All pictures: Photocall Ireland)

WATCH: Remember these seven from #Áras11?

Read: Guess which #Áras11 candidate spent the most on their campaign?

Read next:

Comments (33 Comments)

  • Dana is clearly still reeling from the traumatic effects of that subversive attack on her car in which someone clearly intended to take her out of the race because of her popularity. Or was it a puncture…

    Reply
    • @ Hugh O’Connell,

      I am disgusted with the slap dash, misuse of the English language you have shown here. How dare you misrepresent Senator Norris. You accuse Senator Norris of being a ‘failure’. My dear Mr. O’Connell, he is far from being a failure.

      Being a so called democracy, David Norris had every right to be on the ballet paper. Many believe in true democracy in this country if you don’t! I for one do! I fought to have Senator Norris on my ballot paper and refused to be told that I’d to vote for someone I did not have a preference for.

      Thankfully, in many ways David Norris did win. That is all he wanted, was to have the right to be on my/our ballot paper. Being President was a bonus. The 2nd best man won. A truly great friend and fighter for human rights in this country and for your children, if you ever have the privilege of having one. He has made it possible for gay people to live in peace and have the same bloody rights as you and many others.

      I will never be posting on journal.ie ever again and I would hope that you apologise to David Norris and all gays and heterosexuals in this article. Take the time to read the interviews, many of which were done on what Senator Norris did actually speak about and not what you assumed he said. Good bye.

      Reply
    • @ Sheila, I am disgusted at your illiteracy, I have read the article 3 times now and can see no reference to Sen. Norris as a failure, care to clarify your comments? If not I suggest it is you who should be apologising, to the author.

      And to state my own preference, I voted for Sen. Norris and was glad to see him re-enter the race. He ran, the electorate spoke, loudly, and the result announced, that is a democracy, not simply shouting down those you disagree with.

      Reply
    • @Shelia Byrne

      “I would hope that you apologise to David Norris and all gays and heterosexuals in this article.”

      Why are you bringing sexuality into this?That has absolutely nothing to do with the above article! Nothing false was stated about Norris or the others as far as I can see and, please correct me if I am wrong, but the author of the article did not at any stage question anyone’s right to be on the ballot paper.

      The only thing the Norris campaign did bring into question was the process that someone has to go through to be put on the ballot paper and fair play to him for that.The rest of his campaign was nothing short of a farce, a media circus that showed him to be an inappropriate option for head of state.That said,I would take Norris over the Provo any day of the week.

      Reply
    • For get Dana. The salient point is that they all declined interviews. When they wanted votes, they were always available. Now it’s just a shoulder shrug. Sad.

      Reply
  • The best man won for sure a true gentleman in every sense and if we are to spend money on having a president well he is worth every penny !!! And it hasn’t changed him or gone to his head Humble as ever ! Go on Michael D

    Reply
  • What about you? What have you been doing over the last year? Has your life improved? Is your trauma past? Has the “toll” taken in the last year set you back on your trotters?

    Any offers of speaking engagements? Book deals?

    Or, as Tony Soprano said, “Ha ya dooin?”

    Reply
  • The election last year was too dirty for the position on offer. I hope we never see its like again. I understand and accept that we the electorate have the right to question and probe people running for high office but we don’t have the right to destroy them in the process.

    Reply
  • and what first attracted you mary to the 165.000 euro a year job mary ?

    Reply
  • I agree with RealCorkLanger. Sen David Norris fought and with much support, including my self, he did much for democracy in putting his name and names in future elections on the list of candidates for the Presidency. Prospective candidates should not be chosen solely by the so-called political “elite”.

    Reply
  • Sean Gallagher promised to create jobs and enterprise in Ireland if elected. Can’t believe people swallowed that and nearly elected him. The president can do very little to create jobs. That is governments role. He is a greedy fianna fail bagman, nothing more nothing less.

    The president is in effect a symbolic representation of our country. Michael D is doing a great job of promoting the arts and recognising Irish diaspora and their key roles in developing other nations.

    Martin Mcguinness would also have been a worthwhile president in terms of signifying peace and reunification on island of Ireland.

    Reply
  • Who?

    Reply
  • Ireland can do better than this bizarre collection of religious fruit & nuts (particularly the Gay fellow).

    Reply
  • The scary thing is that ‘sean spoofer gallagher’ came so close.

    That he talks of entering the race the next time worries me as goldfish-memory syndrome is really widespread in Ireland.

    Reply
  • and one year after what has the actual president’s job been about beyond stuffing himself at banquets and opening supermarkets. All that pre election boloney and money spent on an absolutely futile position of influence . Get rid and while you’re at it, time to fry the seanad as well

    Reply
  • there still sucking the state dry in some form lying taxpayer waged wanting leeches

    Reply
  • What a shower! Good job the least odious of them won. Never seen such a bunch of losers, a religious fruitcake, a Fianna FAILure bagman, another religious fruitcake still suckling on the EU gravy train, a quangocrat who’s raking it in at a ‘charity’, a nauseating ex terrorist and a man who thinks it’s ok to write letters in support of pedophiles. At least Higgins seems normal compared the the rest of them, is he still being paid a TD’s pensions every year even whilst he’s getting paid to be president? Anyone know the answer? All kinds of everything indeed!

    Reply
  • Dana is clearly still reeling from the traumatic effects of that subversive attack on her car in which someone clearly intended to take her out of the race because of her popularity. Or was it a puncture…

    Reply
  • Who cares where they are, none of them have problems paying there house hold charge.

    Reply
  • And one year after what has the actual president’s job been about beyond stuffing himself at banquets and opening supermarkets. All that pre election boloney and money spent on an absolutely futile position of influence Get rid…..and while you’re at it, time to fry the seanad as well

    Reply
  • NON ARTICLE THEN.

    Reply
  • I have to say Dana is the soundest id have her over for a cuppa anyday pity she was too nice for us Oirish.

    Reply
  • Would AA be of any use to Dana now?

    Reply
  • Jackie Healy-Rae for president.

    Reply

Add New Comment