TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 9 °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

Dean of St. Paul’s Cathedral stepping down

Graeme Knowles said his position has become “untenable” as criticism of the cathedral mounts over how it has handled the Occupy London protests spilling into the church’s grounds.

Graeme Knowles speaks to protesters yesterday.
Graeme Knowles speaks to protesters yesterday.
Image: Sean Dempsey/PA Wire/Press Association Images

THE DEAN OF St Paul’s Cathedral has become the second high-profile clergy member to step down over anti-capitalist protests that have spilled across the historic church’s grounds in London.

The resignation today of Graeme Knowles leaves the cathedral without a leader and will delay a planned legal action to evict the protest camp.

Knowles said his position had become “untenable” as criticism of the cathedral mounted in the press and in public opinion. Knowles had urged protesters to leave the cathedral area to allow it to reopen its doors.

Officials shut the church to the public on 21 October, saying demonstrators’ tents were a health and safety hazard. It was the first time the 300-year-old London church had closed since German planes bombed the city during World War II. It reopened on Friday.

Fear of violence

Knowles’ resignation follows that last week of Giles Fraser, a senior St Paul’s Cathedral priest who had welcomed the anti-capitalist demonstrators to set up camp outside the landmark, inspired by New York’s Occupy Wall Street movement. He said he resigned because he feared moves to evict the protesters could end in violence.

A part-time chaplain, Fraser Dyer, also resigned last week, saying he was “embarrassed” by the decision to take legal action to try to evict the protesters.

Senior clergy have been divided over how to handle the scores of tents set up outside the iconic cathedral near the River Thames in central London. Demonstrators erected the tents October 15, during a thwarted attempt to stage a protest outside the nearby London Stock Exchange.

The protesters said Knowles’ resignation showed that the management of St. Paul’s is “obviously deeply divided” over the protests. But in a statement on the Occupy London website, the movement said it had never called for any “scalps” from the clergy.

“Our cause has never been directed at the staff of the cathedral,” the group said. It called for an “open and transparent dialogue” between demonstrators and those urging campers to move.

Knowles, 60, called the past two weeks a “testing time” and said his decision to step down did not come easily.

Since the arrival of the protesters’ camp outside the cathedral, we have all been put under a great deal of strain and have faced what would appear to be some insurmountable issues,” he said in a statement. “I hope and pray that under new leadership these issues might continue to be addressed and that there might be a swift and peaceful resolution.”

St Paul’s officials said Knowles made his decision known on Sunday night and has already removed himself from operations.

Yesterday, clergymen and demonstrators held talks aimed at avoiding a violent confrontation over the camp.

Legal proceedings

Both the church and the local authority, the City of London Corporation, announced last week they were going to court to clear scores of tents from a pedestrianised square and footpath outside the cathedral.

But cathedral spokesman Rob Marshall said legal proceedings had not yet started, and the governing chapter “is now discussing a range of options in the wake of the resignation of the dean.”

Knowles’ resignation does not affect the separate legal action by the City of London Corporation, which is seeking eviction on the grounds that the protest is an “unreasonable user of the highway.”

Britain’s High Court will decide whether to allow authorities to forcibly clear the protest camp. Many expect the legal process to be lengthy and complex.

Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, leader of the Anglican church, called Knowles’ decision to step down “very sad news.”

“The events of the last couple of weeks have shown very clearly how decisions made in good faith by good people under unusual pressure can have utterly unforeseen and unwelcome consequences, and the clergy of St Paul’s deserve our understanding in these circumstances,” he said in a statement.

“The urgent larger issues raised by the protesters at St. Paul’s remain very much on the table and we need – as a church and as society as a whole – to work to make sure that they are properly addressed.”

Meanwhile, some protesters have dressed as zombie bankers today for a march around the city’s banking district.

More: Tents at St Paul’s Cathedral “were not empty”>

Read: St Paul’s Cathedral priest resigns over Occupy London eviction plan>

Read next:

Comments (10 Comments)

  • It’s a shame that these 2 good men have become entangled in this situation. That benefits no-one.

    Reply
  • Is everyone missing the narrative that is being peddled by AP. the majority of the media are doing likewise.
    None of the demos are at their heart ‘anti-capitalist’, some people are but most are not. They are demonstrating against the inequality that has become a foundation of society.
    Simple stats from the UK out in Oct.
    Of the 100 biggest companies, senior management wages have increased by 49%, the general staff wages in those same 100 companies have increased by 2.5%. This is below 5.2 current inflation level. So actually loosing money.
    This is just one of the disconnects.
    The fact that our puppetry of a government, led by a man shaped object will pay out 700 million to private unsecured bond holders of Anglo this week, when they can’t find 2 million for special needs teachers is disgusting.
    D

    Reply
  • The only reason they’re outside St Paul’s is because they’re not allowed into the “City”. If they let them occupy The “City” they could move overnight.

    Reply
  • BJ 31/10/11 #

    I wonder if the Protesters went for St Paul’s in the knowledge that the Church would probably be a ‘softer’ touch?

    Reply
  • great lead photo

    Reply
  • Why are they protesting outside a Church can they not take it to 10 downing street who pay their benefits.

    Reply
  • DAve in with you. the Church are just as involved, the are conflicted in this moment. cos they built there ‘foundation’ on kindess love and ‘charity, which they dont follow any more, they like any other corporation have amassed enormous fortunes and done nothing to alleviate the poor or the suffering of the world so I say they are in the perfect place to protest.

    As for Anglo and tthis pathetic bunch called The Government. ..That giveaway will begin a tipping point frrom here on in..this will be the winter of discontent not for us for THEM..

    Reply
    • The Churches are big business too. Mother Theresa amassed millions of dollars in her life and used it to promote her order and build convents, very little of none of her fortune was used to help the poor people of Calcutta. Bishops both Anglican and Roman Catholic spend an average of €30,000 on their Ceremonial Clothing including Gold Crosses ridiculous pointed hats, dresses and rings for people to kiss.
      These pompous arrogant idiots are so far removed from reality it is not funny. They are always complaining about money but are able to produce millions to compensate or silence their rape victims.Organized Religion represents the worst hypocrisy of society both modern and ancient and it is time that people see this for what it really is: a destructive parasite.

      Reply
  • Mother Theresa amassed millions of dollars? That is one hell of a lie and completely unfounded.Mother theresa lived a life of complete poverty just like the human beings she looked after.And contrary to what you say she used money to feed and educate the poor.Will you have to look after someone about to die from hunger or no one to care for them Joe,never be critical of those who help the most vunerable of the world. As for £30,000 for vestments for clergy another wild quote.Misinformation of this type is just slander and unfounded half truths.

    Reply

Add New Comment