TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 16 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

EU deal is unlikely to end the crisis in the eurozone – Varadkar

The Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport said that “a lot of people have concerns” about Britain opting out of Friday’s landmark EU deal.

Image: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland

LEO VARADKAR, MINISTER for Transport, Tourism and Sport, has said that the landmark EU deal agreed on Friday is unlikely to be enough to end the crisis in the eurozone.

He also said that the eurozone is already effectively a federal state – but without a central bank that can intervene to fix the ongoing problems.

Speaking on the Marian Finucane Show on RTE Radio 1 this morning, the Minister acknowledged that “a lot of people have concerns about Britain not being in the new fiscal compact”.

The Fine Gael TD said that he believed that fiscal coordination is “a good idea” but that the deal “won’t be enough to solve the problem that we have,” adding:

We are effectively a federation now that we have the same currency, but we don’t have a central bank that acts like a federal reserve.

His comments were echoed by economist David McWilliams on the same programme who  said that he believed that the deal would be ultimately “unsuccessful” but was a step in the direction of a German-dominated EU backed up by France.

The Minister also indicated that a financial transactions tax is unlikely to be introduced throughout Europe.

There was a mixed reaction across Europe to Friday’s crucial EU deal which was a coordinated attempt by eurozone member states to deal with the ongoing crisis.

Separately, speaking about the government u-turn over the controversial Budget plan to cut disability allowances, Minister Varadkar distanced  Fine Gael from the proposal and said that the suggestion had come from Labour ministers.

“No proposal for social welfare cuts came from any Fine Gael minister,” said Varadkar, adding that all the suggestions for cuts came from either the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform under Brendan Howlin or the Department for Social Protection under Joan Burton.

“The impression being created is that Fine Gael came up with this great idea for welfare cuts and that is not the case,” said the Minister, adding that the decisions had been made “collectively”.

Gallery: ‘Bye-Bye England’ – how the world’s press saw the EU deal >

Read more: Government “will revisit” Budget cut to disability allowance >

Read more: Financial transactions tax would be bad for Ireland – FF >

Read next:

Comments (100 Comments)

  • Why is he always the Minister being quoted about situations that have nothing to do with his cabinet portfolio.

    Reply
    • U can bet your last Euro that everything that’s said publicly has been passed & approved, Amy. Nothing is “off the cuff”. If a “clanger” is thrown, it is thrown for a reason, I suspect.

      Reply
    • I guess he’s a member of the cabinet and therefore is privy to most of the negotiations at the cabinet table. The reason he’s always in the news though is because he wants to be. He intentionally says somewhat controversial things to get his ugly mug in the newspapers. He once abused Brian Cowen in the Dail by comparing him to Garrett Fizgerald – the ex-leader of his own party! Basically, he’s a douche-bag.

      Reply
  • Would’ve thought Leo would keep away from that sort of langauge until Fine Gael know if they can squeeze it by without a referendum or not.

    Reply
  • Passing the buck nice and early. He had found his feet in government and the shoes fit nicely.

    Reply
  • Wouldn’t it be interesting to have a euro wide referendum on all of this? Let the entire population of the eu vote on a federal europe? I’m guessing the majority vote would be no?

    Reply
  • What I find ironic about FG and Labour now is that didn’t they stand for election on a platform of FF have lost us our sovereignty and FG and Labour are going to win it back by 2015. what a joke they have given away even more of our sovereignty. Would they have recieved as many votes on a further European integration.platform. I think not.

    Reply
  • Raf 11/12/11 #

    Do people even know that Lisbon Treaty established the EU, ie. the EU did not exist prior to December 2009?

    Does anyone know about the “double majority” voting system coming into play in 2014, that technically gives France, Germany and the UK all the power and does away with vetoes? This is what Lisbon Treaty was all about.

    Reply
  • Believe you me there’ll be no referendum on this issue…….. it’s done and dusted! Even the fact the electorate would probably not pass it is irrelevant. Surely the hard cold reality must be dawning, even amongst the most somnambulist of politicians, the Irish race is done! Which is all good and well if this is what the people want,but; No more standing proud with other NEUTRAL (remember that one) nations hoping for a voice as the superpowers queue to dip your pocket and stunt your dreams! Well, as a result of successive -so called- national governments putting personal cause before national cause we have truely had our pockets dipped, and as for our dreams well as the saying goes dream on. Just about getting over my post-colonial inferiority complex when our elected idiocracy, by handing over our hard earned independence, have me in a tizzy and racing back to the shrink! But hang on maybe it was all a dream………. Irish independence? Nah, of course not, we’re europeans innit?

    Reply
  • unbelievable. The fact that this has been done through lies and deceit makes me sick. Also, the way Leo feels it so unimportant that he can just mention it so blase in an interview just goes to show the standard of statesmen we have representing us. An absolute disgrace

    Reply
    • We are now a banama republic as it is..
      So whats the problem giving the eu more power? We are relying on the americans to call to account our bankers, the imf to sort out the legal, medical and other protected sectors.
      Maybe the eu will sort out the politicians?

      Reply
    • How many of you patriotic geniuses voted YES in the Lisbon Treaty I wonder

      Reply
    • No. Both times.

      I can’t see how any of you think that us ceding power to an undemocratic superstate controlled by the two most powerful states is a good idea. Especially when those states have proven time and time again that they put their interests over that of states on “the periphery”. Europe is rotten to the core, controlled by the financial elite. The transfer of wealth from the bottom to the top will be accelerated now that we are part of the United States of Europe but i suppose once little Ireland has a hand to feed it. The attitude of people in this country really begars belief sometimes.

      Reply
  • The sell out is complete. ;-(

    Reply
    • “Will German, French or Dutch inscribe the epitaph of Emmet?
      When we have sold enough of Ireland to be but strangers in it.
      For What Died the Sons of Róisín, was it greed?”

      -Luke Kelly, 1970.

      Reply
    • Where is the one man EU propaganda machine Gary Clowry today? Gary “SHOW ME PROOF, SHOW ME THE BASIS OF YOUR CONSPIRACY THEORIES THAT WE ARE BECOMING A FEDERAL STATE” Clowry, TheJournals number one EU fan!

      Give me strength!

      Reply
    • On a lighter note Magic you were right. Linda Martin stole the show.

      Reply
    • Johnny Logan will always be the one for me. I can hear Enda Kenny on his hands and knees now singing to his EU overlords….”Hold me now, don’t cry, don’t say a word nowww. Well always be together, forever and everrrr, what do we say when our words are not enoughhhhhhhhhhh…hhhhhhhhhh”

      Great to see so much anti EU sentiments in the country recently, the sheep are finally waking up!!

      Reply
    • Ah magic my man. You see we are all entitled to our opinion, you are, I am and Leo Varadkar is. So what we have here is his opinion, no facts. It’s also an opinion which may well be taken out of context based on the the entirety of what he said. I have no idea though as I didn’t hear the interview.
      One thing is for sure if any proposal is put forward by the EU that effects our sovereignty we will be having a referendum. And I shall read what is in it and then decide what way to vote. What I won’t be doing is judging the proposal based on one quote from Leo Varadkar because that would be stupid.

      Reply
    • Ah my migraine has returned. Hello Gary :)

      Quotes from The European Unions number one fan, the one man Propaganda Machine..Gary Clowry:

      “those who believe there is a federalist Europe now against all the evidence to the contrary, including the constitutional court judgement in Germany are possibly conspiracy theorists.”

      “When someone shouts about the President of the EU when no such role exists”

      “And the epic stupidity of it all you are calling for us to vote no to a future treaty which might well be in our interests”

      Give me strength!

      Reply
    • Thanks for posting my quotes. Is there something factually incorrect about them? Something can you’ll be able to prove, rather than just post your opinion again.

      Reply
    • @Gary Same old answer, answering in riddle…its like listening to Mini Me Sarcozy for the millionth time ))

      “Those who believe there is a federalist Europe now against all the evidence to the contrary, including the constitutional court judgement in Germany are possibly conspiracy theorists.” Gary Clowry

      So might Leo Varadkar be a conspiracy theorist also Gary?

      Gary, stop…I am actually embarrassed for you

      Reply
    • And what I said is still factually correct. You seem to have trouble with the difference between opinion and provable fact.

      Reply
    • FACT: (fkt) 1. Knowledge or information based on real occurrences: an account based on fact; a blur of fact and fancy.
      2.Something demonstrated to exist or known to have existed:

      Leo Varadkar: “We are effectively a federation now”. It is his opinion, he said that…it is a FACT Gary.

      Gary Clowry: “Those who believe there is a federalist Europe now against all the evidence to the contrary, including the constitutional court judgement in Germany are possibly conspiracy theorists.”…that is your opinion, you did say that…it is a FACT

      You have never actually answered anybody’s questions here Gary, you side step each question because you are only capable of reading from your propaganda sheets and Political sound-bites. So Ill ask you once again, do you also believe Leo Varadkar is a Conspiracy Theorist?

      Reply
    • I’ll help you out here, this is what the German constitutional court said
      “It held that the Lisbon Treaty does not transform the EU into a federal state and such a transformation would have been contrary to domestic German law. It also held that the Lisbon Treaty does create an EU citizenship to supersede a national one, and does not oblige member states to provide troops for a European army. In essence, the Constitutional Court finds that the member States of the EU wield the political power.”
      http://eulaw.typepad.com/eulawblog/2009/07/german-constitutional-court-and-lisbon-treaty-ratification.html
      http://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/pressemitteilungen/bvg09-072en.html

      So do I accept the word the of these constitutional experts or some random bloke on the internet with an agenda?
      See facts can be fun.

      Reply
    • :) Ill try asking him again. Gary do you also believe Leo Varadkar is a Conspiracy Theorist?

      Reply
    • Oh and Magic it may well be a fact that ole Leo said those words but they are his *opinion*. It’s pretty simple.

      Reply
    • LEO VARADKAR: “We are effectively a federation now”.

      GARY CLOWRY: “Those who believe there is a federalist Europe now against all the evidence to the contrary, including the constitutional court judgement in Germany are possibly CONSPIRACY THEORISTS.”

      :) This is quite embarrassing but Ill try asking him again. Gary do you also believe Leo Varadkar is also possibly a Conspiracy Theorist?

      Reply
    • I would doubt he’s a conspiracy theorist. You might notice where I used the word *possibly*, you seem to have trouble with comprehension. I’ve just shown you how constitutional experts think your *opinion* is wrong. It also shows that a federalist EU would be contrary to German law. I’m off back to my life. Though if you ever manage to find proof for anything you say let me know.

      Reply
    • Gary are you sure I am the one with the comprehension problem? Me:” Leo Varadkar is also “possibly” a Conspiracy Theorist? :)

      Gary Clowry: “I would doubt he’s a conspiracy theorist” So, anybody else who shares Leo Varadkars opinion is “possibly” a conspiracy theorist, but you doubt Leo is one.

      Thank you for clearing that up Gary :):):)

      Reply
  • What the hell is Varadkar talking about – “the Financial Transaction Tax is unlikely to be introduced throughout Europe”? It will be – in the EU26 (EU27 minus UK). That was one of the points agreed by the European leaders.

    Reply
  • So jim corr was right

    Reply
  • He doesn’t seem too bothered does he? How annoying is that? You are Out of touch with the people mr.vradkar.

    Reply
  • Simon 11/12/11 #

    This article seems to suggest that there is a growing rift between Labour and Fine Gael. No collective responsibility….hope it continues.

    Reply
  • The good old media in Ireland did a great job making jim corr look like a loony. They will do same again in next few months leading up to a referendum.

    Reply
    • What hope does a “nation” with the population of only 5 million have in the “Federal States of Europe”?? Absolutely none. Our politicians and media have lied and deceived us for years over the real aims of the EU. All dissenting voices were shouted down, ridiculed and discredited, and now they have us were they want us. Unless the people of Ireland wake up and reject this totalitarianism through a referendum then we will become little more than servants of colonial masters, yet again.

      Reply
    • actually he did that all by himself

      Reply
    • u should know stephen,
      being the expert at it urself.

      Reply
  • The fact that enda gave his ‘state of the nation’ address with the irish flag to his right and the eu flag to his left kind of gave the game away!
    Dont know why the politicos are so upset by britain being no longer so allied to us. Most politicos got elected on the retoric of ‘that lot dun us wrong’.
    Interesting times we live in!

    Reply
  • Ciaro 11/12/11 #

    What a slimeball, blaming labour on disability cuts. It’s FF/GP all over again

    Reply
  • I’m guessing that FG don’t want to win the referendum (at least the Varadkar branch of it!)

    Reply
  • CJ Ryan 11/12/11 #

    This agreement to make an agreement (The treaty summit is not till next year) does NOT create a federation alá the USA.

    Rather like the USSR or the historical UK/British Empire it is a move to a political union which primarily benefits the dominant state/s in the union (like Russia and England in the given examples) with the weaker countries as vassal states.

    A 27- member agreement within the EU structures would have been a step towards a federation with all countries losing sovereignty to Brussels. (The Germans would have preferred this)

    The outcome of this weeks summit has resulted in an agreement to a future inter-governmental treaty OUTSIDE of the EU institutions. (A preference by the French)

    Since most of the future treaty will be a Franco-German dictat they won’t lose sovereignty but every other country will.

    Reply
  • Leo Varadkar really needs to STFU.

    Reply
  • I’m sick of the euro. Blah blah for last 3 years- everyday all day. I would have been happy to leave it. Start from scratch . People can say this that the other about what would happen if we left it. But whatever – we would have stuck together and resolved or own issues« ps we better have a referendum :-p

    Reply
  • Varadkar. You are one dull, droning, jobsworth of an excuse for a statesman. Will ya get a bit of shift about ya or go back to pen pushing. Minister of tourism me b***ix? You could’t attract flies to Sh**e .

    Reply
  • how they can keep straight faces after the adviser scandal – it seems the Irish will accept any form of abuse now that FF are gone – we are our own worst enemies…

    Reply
  • And you are effectively an egit Varadkar

    Reply
  • doesnt matter, our economic system only creates debt and with our exponential based population the time has arrived when the whole system comes crashing down. on top of this we will/(or have) hit peak oil, and peak resources. the smart guys are doing the numbers and realise this cant last especially when driven by a debt based system….

    Reply
  • Considering the calibre of politicians and advisers we have in Ireland at the moment, it’s a grim moment when I find myself thinking the alternative being presented might be better.

    Reply
  • Varadker has admitted that Fg are willfully handing over sovereignty so any debate on a referendum is void, his words automatically kick starts a vote so what i’m wondering, will FG put “VOTE YES FOR INTEGRATION” on their posters or just wheel out the usual bullshit of “VOTE YES FOR JOBS”.
    Will they lie again or tell the truth?

    Reply
    • The one poster I am expecting in the next referendum is “VOTE YES FOR BETTER WEATHER” Sad thing is, the majority of Irish people probably would think they were promised better weather :(

      They will lie again, as always….they know where their expenses and pensions are coming from

      Reply
    • Probably a combination of both. Vote yes for european integration or else face economic ruin? Perhaps

      Reply
    • I doubt they’ll be able to sell this without hiding the fact that this is a full surrender of sovereignty, all his bullshit about getting back our fiscal sovereignty by 2015 rings hollow now, just like all his other lies.

      Reply
  • so its the end of the Republic of Ireland. Time to sign up for the German classes

    Reply
  • ” unlikely to be enough to end the crisis in the eurozone.” We know this ..

    Reply
  • “Leo the lick” god help the country when we have this idiot and “Lucy Creton” in power. Sadly I voted for Summerville and these 2 FG are cringe worthy. Between both of them it would be hard to find 1 intelligent brain cell. These idiots are leading us toward the cliff.

    Reply
  • Enda Merkensi is European first, Irish second. or maybe German second , Irish third. Either way he’s been reduced,, er I mean seduced into a European gangbang that will end in tears

    Reply
  • Anyone have any idea if a referendum will be likely?

    Reply
    • Seeing that britain has vetoed it. I would say that there now has to be a referendum.

      Reply
    • If our government is handing over sovereignty to a foreign state or regime then it has by constitutional law be put to the people but it’s FG we’re dealing with, they’ll not let a simple thing like our democratic rights stand in the way of their plans.
      No doubt they will wheel out some excuse that it’s not surrender and that Kenny is doing this in the national interest, anyway, if we do vote and vote it down can you trust these quislings to respect our decision?

      Reply
  • ”We are effectively a federation now that we have the same currency, but we don’t have a central bank that acts like a federal reserve” That is a treacherous comment if I ever heard one . I am sick of this .

    Reply
  • I knew, but everyone told me I was crazy.

    Reply
  • Has anyone else noticed the change in the language the EU ‘elected’ have been using for quite some time? They no longer refer to ‘countries’ but to ‘member states’. All psychological softening up and paving of the way for the conversion of the 1946 plan to create, as they surely will, the United States of Europe. 1916 and the deaths of all those wild, wonderful, colourful and very brave characters a complete waste of time. :(

    Reply
    • Is that the latest lie that you are using about the EU? Just for the record, the phrase “member states” has been used generally and is in the European treaties from the very start. What will your next nationalist lie be?

      Reply
    • That’s a bit ott there. Can’t recall anyone being tied to a chair and executed in the name of further European integration. The actions of the 1916 heroes gave us the independence to choose democratically to join the EEC. While I accept a United States of Europe seems to be the aim of Germany & France we will, I presume, still be given the democratic opportunity to express our wishes at the ballot box. Like it or not that democracy in action.. Even if we change our mind ala Lisbon 2 we have a choice.

      Reply
    • Euro sheep…beyond brainwashed

      Reply
  • We are creating a new age of empires. Some of the European countries what an empire which they control.

    Reply
  • @Ardoci the deaths of the men and women of 1916 will be even more watsed if we go for option B – joing sterling and the UK!

    Reply
  • Our corporation tax will be lost now – similarly if the uk had signed up their financial services would have left the eu altogether and set up where there was no regulation.

    Reply
  • Ná mé ag féach sin ar bhfuill ??

    Reply
  • Varadkar is a true patriot. Sure isn’t he originally one of the Varadkars of the Aran Islands?

    Reply
  • first we take sterling, then we drop the senate, then enter C’wealth then UK…

    Reply
    • We’ve more in common with the British than we do with the Europeans.

      Reply
    • Please be consitent, the senate is just as undemocratic.
      Go look up past members of the senate please, its been full of the same gobshites who graced the dail. Mary Harney comes to mind.
      Usually they flee to the senate when they know nobody in their right mind would vote for them into the dail again. Then you have the ones who start off in the senate and move on to show how useless they are in the dail.
      There is no place for the senate in modern Ireland. The concept of a political body which rejects the opinion of everyone except for the university graduates is stupid. University graduates aren’t inherintly more up to date politically as an IT graduate or a members of local community groups actively trying to improve their society.
      If your going to argue that the ceding powers to the EU is undemocratic which I agree with then don’t blabber on about how much of a loss abolishing an institution which ignores the will of the people is.

      Reply
    • On a second reading of your comment it looks as though you aren’t in favor of the senate so scratch that previous comment. With regards to joinging the C’welth and sterling.
      I think its intelectually dishonest to leave the euro to join the sterling.
      I much prefer the idea of going it alone and maybe building a good relationship with Britain.
      If you just join the commonwelth you are left in the same situation we are in now where the people who bankrupted the country still retain control.

      We may need to build a stronger relationship with countries like Iceland though. At this point we have more in common with Iceland. Britain are protecting the Icelandic bankers who bankrupted their country and refusing to release them to Icelandic authorities. London is making a name for itself for being a place to go when you are wanted for financial fraud.
      This is disgraceful in my mind and should not be tolerated. We need to form alliances with people who want justice served and reform of the financial sector.
      Icelandic officials have already stated that Irish Politicians have not been in communication with them and that they would be more than willing to give some advice and help, they said the same for other peripheral countries which are being bullied into corners atm.

      Oh and as for Leo’s admisssion – By definition the difference between are confederation and a federation is that the many memberships of the member states in a confederation are voluntary, while the membership in a federation is not.

      In other words he thinks its a good thing that we have no choice anymore. What a guy.

      Reply
    • And the europhobic game plan is laid bare … returning this country to the warm embrace of Mother England.

      Reply

Add New Comment