Readers like you keep news free for everyone.

More than 5,000 readers have already pitched in to keep free access to The Journal.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can help keep paywalls away.

Support us today
Not now
Sunday 10 December 2023 Dublin: 9°C
Independence Day

People are outraged over actress swap in 'Independence Day 2'

Fox has not yet given a reason for why Mae Whitman wasn’t considered for the sequel.

mae-whitman-independence-day Business Insider Mae Whitman in Independence Day scene. Business Insider

PEOPLE ARE NOT too happy about the recasting of president’s daughter in the upcoming sequel to ‘Independence Day’.

News broke that Maika Monroe — an on-the-rise actress from recent independent movie hits like ‘It Follows’ and ‘The Guest’ — had been cast in the role.

69th Venice Film Festival - Day 4 - 'The Master' Premiere Andrew Medichini Actress Maika Monroe Andrew Medichini

Re-casting the role 

The casting was initially a minor item highlighting how Monroe is climbing up the Hollywood ranks, but the problem for many is the news meant that the actress who initially played the role in the original 1996 film was now getting the boot.

Young actress Mae Whitman played the president’s daughter in the first “Independence Day.”

NY Special Screening Of The Duff AP / Press Association Images Mae Whitman AP / Press Association Images / Press Association Images

The role launched Whitman’s successful acting career, which has included starring roles in hit TV series ‘Parenthood’ and most recently the successful teen comedy, ‘The Duff,’ which stands for ‘Designated Ugly Fat Friend.’


Fans of Whitman, now 26, quickly came to her defense after the casting news.

People on social media have been calling out Fox, the studio behind the “Independence Day” sequel, for allegedly recasting the role with a more “conventionally hot” actress to play opposite Liam Hemsworth, who will reportedly be the love interest of Monroe’s character.

Even actress Anna Kendrick took to Twitter to voice her displeasure with the recasting:

Whitman has been quiet about the decision, though she did reply to Kendrick with this:

HitFix‘s Drew McWeeny reports that Whitman didn’t even make the shortlist of actors for the role and he thinks the reason is obvious:

“…the oh-so-cute actors whose names were on the list all seem to be more of a conventionally ‘hot’ type than Whitman, making it look clearly like they were chasing a certain something.”

But over at ScreenCrush, Britt Hayes called out her male colleagues who think they’ve rushed to judgement that the decision by Fox was solely based on looks.

“The prevalent thinking I’m seeing from a lot of my male writers on Twitter is that Whitman is not ‘conventionally attractive,’ and therefore Fox went with someone who is. This thinking is offensive on various levels. First of all, comparing the attractiveness of two women, even in an attempt to rationalize a disagreeable situation such as this one, is awful and perpetuates a competitive culture in which women are forced to examine themselves through the lens of what men find attractive. That this was the first speculated narrative is unfortunate — and whether or not it’s true, it’s depressing to see men I respect insisting that a woman wasn’t hired because she’s just not pretty enough….”

Monroe has also been mum about the controversy. Only tweeting an article announcing the casting.

Fox has not yet given a reason for why Whitman wasn’t considered for the sequel.

Read: Man’s ear bitten off in fast food restaurant>

Read: This swan was saved by gardaí after a nasty run-in with Luas cables>

Published with permission from
Business Insider
Your Voice
Readers Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.