TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Sunday 26 May, 2013

Department defends underspend as unemployment stays at 14.8 per cent

The Department of Jobs has said that its performance must relate to services delivered and not money spent as figures show it underspent by €85 million in the first three quarters of 2012.

Jobs Minister Richard Bruton with a picture of football superstar Lionel Messi
Jobs Minister Richard Bruton with a picture of football superstar Lionel Messi
Image: Mark Stedman/Photocall Ireland

THE DEPARTMENT OF Jobs has defended its budget underspend for the first nine months of this year as unemployment figures yesterday showed the rate of joblessness was virtually unchanged.

Exchequer figures released on Tuesday showed that the Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation underspent its estimated budget to the end of September of €499 million by 17 per cent or around €85 million.

This includes €16 million designated for current expenditure and €69 million in expenditure on capital projects that was not spent, the third highest amount in percentage terms of any government department after the Departments of Communications and Environment.

The figures were followed yesterday by news from the Central Statistics Office that 400 people had come off the Live Register in September, a statistically insignificant change as the number of those unemployed stayed at 14.8 per cent.

The Department insisted yesterday that any assessment of its performance must relate to the level of services delivered and not the amount of money spent.

“In this context, it is important to note that well over 90 per cent of the measures committed to be delivered under the Action Plan for Jobs have been delivered on time, and that both Enterprise Ireland and IDA are performing well in terms of exports and job creation so far in 2012,” a statement said.

Sinn Féin’s Peadar Tóibín was critical of the government following the release of the latest Live Register numbers and said that the underspend of €69 million was “astounding” when skilled trades workers were on the dole or else emigrating.

“It is now clear that the Ministers must take responsibility for their underperforming department and the government take responsibility for getting our people back to work,” he said in a statement yesterday.

In its statement to TheJournal.ie, the Department added: “The Department adopts a careful and prudent approach in relation to the spending of taxpayers’ money.

“Issues in relation to the timing of expenditure mean that some spending which was scheduled to take place by this particular point in the year has not yet been drawn down.

“However it is expected that this snapshot statistic will not be reflected in the end of year figure. For example, the new Microfinance Scheme, as launched by Minister Bruton on 27th September, is now open for business which will have associated exchequer expenditure of €10m before year end.”

Read: Live register figures virtually unchanged in September

Read: Exchequer returns show tax take up but deficit at over €11bn

Read next:

Comments (43 Comments)

  • Bruce 04/10/12 #

    Well does that not just sum up this government. They are content with 440,000 people idle.

    There are tens of thousands of people looking for very small funding (less than ?5k) to get started. Bruton fidddles while people lie idle.

    Where is the SMALL stimulus households need to get spending going – there are households with savings?

    Where is the stimulus to reward people for buying goods and services from the WHITE economy?

    Labour and FG are obsessed with their spats and have abandoned the Irish people.

    Reply
  • Dave P 04/10/12 #

    This government are nothing but a bunch of spin doctors. Of the 400 people that came off the live register in September the CSO fails to say that the majority of these were probably teachers and school workers that sign on for the summer. How many of these 400 went on to government funded schemes like Tús and the like? Underspending in one of the most important departments in this day and age shows that they don’t have a clue what they are doing.

    Reply
  • We’re all happy to see money not being wasted but this is money specifically to help create employment

    Reply
  • The five point plan will create 100,000 jobs. Enda said it, so it must be true. Maybe we should ask David Higgins about the latest regarding this plan! He’s a pal of Enda’s, is he not?

    Reply
    • 50/290/90 job losses daily but ohhhhhh it’s ok because 4 were ‘created’ least we forget business closing everyday, this should of been redirected in enterprise and small start ups.

      Reply
  • They could create jobs in Longford as the office that processes the invalidity benefit is 6 months or more behind. People are committing suicide all over Ireland as they despair at the lack of urgency in dealing with the welfare of the less well off. If it happened in the passport office it would be dealt with pretty quickly. Are passports for holidays more important than people’s lives?

    Reply
    • Correct Frank. The Family income supplement crowd are just as bad. The amount of people turning down low income jobs, because of having to wait 6 months or more to have an application processed must be huge. How is anyone with a family on a minimum wage income supposed to survive that length of time on upwards of €100 less per week than they’d be getting on Jobseeker’s Allowance?

      Reply
  • I think they could form a new department out of the excess money: The Department for the Hopeless and Jobless and Depressed and Suicidal. I don’t think it would be just another quango because it will deal with nearly every person in the country!

    Reply
  • I’d like to know how many jobs they created with the money they have spent

    Reply
  • As someone long-term disemployed and trying to get work, I tracked down a course in Donegal and after six months managed to get FAS to fund it. Although I had bills at home while up there the allowance didn’t cover accommodation fully. Food allowance was forty cents per day. A follow up course they were prepared to stretch to fund did not include funding me..just the course runners. I cant help wondering(given the costs of the courses) if its not another Reilly-type golden circle of insiders. We all are familiar with the selflessness of Fas and out top civil servants being equal to our political ‘representatives’ and their friendly coporate sponsors. More rackets than Wimbledon.

    Reply
  • Why do people always seem obsessed in suggesting that our way out of this unemployment crisis is through setting up small businesses ? The country is flooded with them with record numbers of them are going to the wall , so why will any of these new one survive. Even during the boom, many small businesses failed. I know we need people to show entrepreneurial ambition,best of luck to the man or woman who tries, but many of these business start up schemes etc waste alot of resources and money.

    Reply
    • Damocles 04/10/12 #

      During a boom many small businesses will sring up that have no right to exist, they go to the wall pretty quickly in a downturn. Also businesses that should work but have over extended themselves go to the wall. It is these latter sort that leave market gaps that can be filled, and that will be good as long as these new businesses don’t over extend themselves.

      Reply
    • Some of them are international criminal money getting rinsed.
      The globe is run by a collection of mafiosi, some masquerading as a ‘white’ economy. Many are not even aware of the downstream consequences of their ‘legal’ actions.
      A prime example might be the mercenary war-profiteering of rendition traffic through Eirebase Shannon.
      Omerta in our media ensures such issues remain below the radar of public debate.
      Check out http://www.treasureislands.org for an intro to the offshore outernets.

      Reply
  • they`re spending too much on bondholders and banks and not enuf on REAL job creation…fg/lab clowns

    Reply
  • We need to protest, at least let them know that there are voters wanting change, it’s not going to happen by itself, we need a plan to have strength in numbers, any rallies or groups out there I should know about?

    Reply
  • this is bloody ridicilous…….Prudent with tax payers money??????????…….they are giving away billions of tax payers money 2 bondholders……….Illl bet you wont print this comment…..

    Reply
    • Liam

      Can you remember why the Bondholders shouldn’t have recovered their investments in Ireland?
      Was it;
      Because we don’t have to repay money we borrow?
      We need the money more than they do?
      They’re not Irish so it doesn’t matter?
      The money was from Pension Funds and since you didn’t bother with one you’ll happily rob others?
      Some or all of the above ?
      It’s so long ago I just get to hear the mantra nowadays and it’s all from the same vocal left wing minority

      Reply
    • No paddy
      It was that the people repaying the mega-gamblers losses are not the speculators who put what we thought was their shirt on the Plastic Tiger nag..only it turns out to be our kids’ winter coats.

      Reply
    • Paddy it is evident your loaded otherwise the minority left would be apealling to you since the majority right have put every man woman and child in the red for the foreseeable future.How do you deal with poor people! the worst advice you can get is from a rich person in this country.

      Reply
  • Lionel Messi announces expansion of his Psychic Call Center operation in Louth with the creation of 50 new jobs. Richard Bruton says “Love, relationship and career advice all in one?, Leos the man.”

    Reply
  • Am I the only one happy to see a government department NOT spending loads of money?

    Reply

Add New Comment