#Open journalism No news is bad news

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support The Journal
Dublin: 11°C Thursday 15 April 2021

Online dating scammer who tricked ‘vulnerable’ woman into giving him €18,950 gets suspended sentence

Alan Custy pleaded guilty to the scam and has repaid the money.

Judge Gerald Keys imposed the sentence at Ennis Circuit Court.
Judge Gerald Keys imposed the sentence at Ennis Circuit Court.
Image: Shutterstock

A JUDGE TOLD smooch.com swindler, Alan Custy that he “is very, very lucky” as the con-man was about to walk free from court.

At Ennis Circuit Court, Judge Gerald Keys made his comment after imposing a suspended three year jail term on Custy for ripping €18,950 off from a vulnerable, gullible, trusting woman he met online.

Custy (42) of Dun na hInse, Ennis hatched a scheme where he stole by deception around €18,950 from the ‘vulnerable’ woman he met through the dating website smooch.com over five months in 2013.

The 47-year old Limerick woman, who lives alone, was the second online female victim of the scheming Custy who previously received a three-year suspended jail term in February 2012 for blackmailing a married woman who he met on connectedsingles.com.

In that case, Custy posed as a Michael Lynch and in the smooch.com case, the father-of-two posed as an Alan Casey.
In sentencing today, Judge Keys said that he regarded Custy’s previous conviction for a similar offence as an aggravating factor in the case and viewed it as “very, very serious”.
In relation to Custy’s most recent offence, Judge Keys said that the way he obtained the monies from the woman was ‘terrible and horrible”.

Counsel for Custy, Pat Whyms BL said that his client has paid off the entire €18,950 to the woman and his final instalment was €750.

Whyms said that the €750 was €400 more than required but that his client indicated that the additional amount be paid to the woman. Whyms said that his client has apologised for his behaviour.

He said: “Mr Custy is a working man and he has been working for the last three years to repay this debt.”


Judge Keys said that the mitigating factors in the case were that Mr Custy has pleaded guilty; has repaid all of the monies and has not come to the attention of the gardaí since his plea of guilty in 2015.

Judge Keys said that he would suspend the three-year term for four years.

Det Garda Claire O’Shaughnessy previously told the court that the female victim in the case lives alone and was trusting, gullible, had health problems and suffered from self-esteem issues when looking for romance online in June 2013.

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal

Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you

Support us now

At the sentencing hearing in relation to the smooch.com case, Det O’Shaughnessy said that the victim had become suspicious of Custy and contacted gardaí in November 2013 after coming across an online newspaper account of his blackmailing case.

However, by that stage, the woman had handed over €18,950 to Custy who said that he needed money to pay off the Revenue; the purchase of plant and machinery; for diesel and the payment of staff who were carrying out fictitious grass cutting contracts with Clare Co Council and Limerick Co Council.

The woman’s victim impact statement read out by Det O’Shaughnessy said Custy’s “abuse of my good nature completely shattered my confidence in men and people in general. I don’t trust my instincts anymore and I have lost confidence in myself”.

She said:

Before I took people at face value and built relationships easily. I am now a nervous participant and suspicious of new people and getting to know them. I am not the same carefree vivacious person I was before I met him.

She said: “On a financial side, my act of kindness ended up with me having to borrow money to pay bills and mortgage, which I am still repaying and will be for a long time to come.”

Det O’Shaughnessy said that the Garda investigation involved going through hundreds of emails and text messages while stating that Custy and the woman met several times after making initial contact through smooch.com.

About the author:

Gordon Deegan

Read next:


This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
write a comment

    Leave a commentcancel