TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Thursday 20 June, 2013

Aer Lingus to Ryanair: Your bid undervalues us

As shares closed up at €1.09 tonight, Aer Lingus said that the bid of €1.30 per share from Ryanair undervalued it.

Image: Niall Carson/PA Wire/Press Association Images

THE BOARD OF Aer Lingus has said that it considers Ryanair’s offer to pay €1.30 for the 70 per cent of shares it does not own “undervalues” it and has raised doubts about the bid’s viability under competition rules.

As shares in the Irish airline closed at €1.09 this evening, up over 15 per cent from yesterday, the board said in a statement that there were a number of “uncertainties and risks” relating to the bid – Ryanair’s third in six years.

Aer Lingus said that Ryanair’s offer – which totals €694 million – comes at a time when its current 29.82 per cent stake in the airline is already under investigation by the Competition Commission (CC) in the UK.

“Ryanair is now under a legal prohibition from undertaking any further integration with Aer Lingus without the consent of the CC and may be subject to an order to sell down its shares at the end of the CC investigation,” Aer Lingus said in a statement.

The statement also noted that two previous bids for the airline had been blocked by the European Commission in 2006 – when Ryanair bid €1.48 billion – while another offer two years later – when it offered €748 million – was withdrawn.

“Consequently there is significant uncertainty that any offer from Ryanair, if made, would be capable of completion,” the statement added.

Earlier the matter arose in the Dáil where Taoiseach Enda Kenny said that the government would not be pushed into any “fire sale” of its 25 per cent stake in the airline.

Read: Aer Lingus tells shareholders to ‘take no action’ following Ryanair bid

Read: Kenny says government ‘won’t be pushed into fire sale’ of Aer Lingus shares

Poll: Should Ryanair be allowed to buy Aer Lingus?

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (32 Comments)

  • Id say it certainly undervalues them in reality. But Not as far as the markets are concerned.
    If BA (IAG) made a similar offer now lets say €1.40 The government would sell them their shares as would ryanair sell them their 30% giving IAG or a similar group 55% and control of the airline at a similar cost.
    There wouldn’t as much of an issue because it wouldn’t create an 80% monopoly.

    Which brings it down to, Aerlingus are now a public company, They are worth what the market says they are worth which was under €1 per share on monday. Ryanair have in a sense raised the value of Aerlingus with their offer.

    Which i suspect is their intention. Flush out another buyer so they can get out.

    Reply
    • And do you know what, Ryanair dispensing of their shares will be the best thing to happen to Aer Lingus! nnThey will be able to continue their sustained and profitable growth without constant interruption by questioning FR Shareholders and other more appropriate investors will be more attracted to them then they would be if MOL is still connected!

      Reply
  • Fair enough, Aer Lingus had exclusivity to UK for years and fleeced the punter then, until Ryanair got a foot in the door to Stansted when Aer Lingus were prevented from competing with them on that route. We don’t want a repetition of that one way at our price off this island.

    Reply
  • Dave 21/06/12 #

    So, th logic is – Ryanair are great for competition, so we should remove the competition. Sorry, does not make sense!

    Reply
  • Aidan 20/06/12 #

    Keep Ryanair separate to Aer Lingus please! I’ll do anything not to fly with Ryanair unless I’ve no other choice.

    Reply
  • Jackie. Is there any chance you could repeat that in English please. Maybe with the odd full stop or comma too, please

    Reply
  • I will make u an offer you cant refuse…..ha ha ha

    Reply
    • What a highly intelligent comment to make on such a serious subject. The future of air travel to and from this island is of critical importance to our economy and requires a broad debate rather than the kicking of cans down a so called alley way!

      Reply
  • aer lingus are one of the best airlines in the world pleasent staff smooth flights excellent pilots with second to none training its one of the few things left to be proud of in this country ryan air in comparison are the exact opposite shit service rude staff and fair ground flights… keep aer lingus seperate they are streets ahead

    Reply
    • Aer Lingus one of the best airlines in the world? You need to get out a but more Stephen. Best trained pilots?nSo what is it that Aer Lingus pilots train in that other airlines don’t?nExamples please.

      Reply
  • For gods sake! Ye wouldn’t be able to afford to leave the country only for O’Leary! In fact only for him ye wouldn’t know what the inside of a plane looks like! He brings more people into this country than AL could ever hope to. Ye know exactly what ya get on Ryanair. If you want more then pay through the nose for it. Ye will be glad of Ryanair in a while cos ye won’t have a pot to piss in soon! Ye bunch of poncy snobs. !

    Reply
    • Gerard 20/06/12 #

      wow Jordan ,spoken like a true ryanair employee

      Reply
    • Dave 21/06/12 #

      Actually, No. Aer lingus bring more people into Ireland than Ryanair now. Also, Ryanair are not the only low fare airline out there..so its not all down to O’Leary. Air travel was deregulated and competition encouraged across Europe – someone was bound to step in. The market was opened up – Ryanair didnt open it up.

      Reply
    • Dave please! Only fro Ryanairs dogged persistence in harrying FF govt to level the playing field in air travel to Ireland we’d still be paying €250.00 one way to London. Only for Seamus Brennan had the balls to come out and do the honest thing and open up the routes to London and see the union stroking for what it was we’d be holidaying in the bogs still!

      Reply
    • Jordan.nWrong wrong wrong.nSaying if it wasn’t for Ryanair we couldn’t afford to leave the island is like saying if Thomas Edison didn’t invent the lightbulb we would be still using candles.nCan we put to bed this myth.nRyanair didn’t bring about low cost travel. Deregulation did. Easy Jet, Air Berlin, Wizz Air etc. all came to life at the same time as Ryanair went low cost. If it wasn’t Ryanair in Dublin it would be Easyjet.

      Reply
    • Dave 21/06/12 #

      John, the EU ordered the deregulation of air transport across the union. It was sweet FA to do with FF despite what they like to claim.

      Reply
  • Are all the red thumbs from Ryan air employees?

    Reply
  • There is an assumption that there are more appropriate investors available. IAG has bigger fish to fry. No one else has a geographical match and no one wants to pay to get into competition with Ryanair. etihad might play but they are constrained as to the shareholding they can take.

    Reply
    • the only ones with the money and legality to buy the would be ish, luftansa or possibly easyjet. (as far as I can see) IAG might not even be allowed buy them because of the amount of Heathrow slots that comes with, easyjet would do well to with the medium haul network, but Ryanair and aerlingus fairly thumped easyjet out of Ireland already. and I just don’t see luftansa being interested their fleet is allready huge including its subsidiaries.
      Biggest question is I guess can they survive alone. They have lost passenger numbers over the last few years, but remain profitable for now..

      Reply
    • Etihad are an obvious potential buyer if they’re interested. A Plc can’t be undervalued if the potential buyer is offering over 30% above the market rate so nobody should stand in their way

      Reply
    • Etihad can’t own a controlling share, no non EU airline can.

      Reply
  • Say no no no no no…….to Michael O’Leary.

    Reply
  • An o’leary ransom. Never.

    Reply
  • Headlines is 100% correct.

    Reply
    • 22 red thumbs and 8 green. Shows a true measure of Irish society. 2/3 are happy for a shit service and happy to be treated like an animal in acceptance of both on flight as well as cancellations while almost 1/3 feel they deserve better in life while traveling either for work reasons or that once a year . On that family holiday.Think about it but either way I expect approx. 66% reds and 33 % green . It’s called self respect .

      Reply
  • sean i dont need to give examples the general feeling here as you can plainly see from the majority of comments is aer lingus is favoured by most… I think I said one of the best I should have said the best. ryan air would be likened to the battered honda civic as opposed to the rolls royce of aer lingus..ryan air has no style or customer focus.

    Reply
  • Does anyone know why Ryanair appear to have exclusivity between Dublin and Stansted? It’s my closest airport, but would love another option when visiting home.

    Reply
  • Gerard, I have no connection with Ryanair what-so-ever bar flying with them when it suits. I just appreciate a company that does exactly what it says on the tin. If you dont like Ryanair, dont fly them! Use someone else and good luck to you! All you’re doing is being extravagant with your ould fellas money, ya muppet! Far from airplane travel you were reared!

    Reply
  • I won’t even take my family on Ryanair Flight.nUsually go Aer Lingus, less hassle when travelling with two kids.nnI won’t let it get me down though, don’t even have bus fare to town so this isn’t gonna affect us at all.nnIf I did have money, I’d be flying my family to a place that runs efficiently!nnNot Ireland!

    Reply
  • No to Ryanair cheap flights ok to uk with 15 kg but going any further like abroad with 15 kg is not on and the rudeness is unreal drinks in a plastic page lol

    Reply
    • Jaqueline!
      You don’t consider the UK abroad? And drinks in a plastic what? Whatever it is, its better than drinking it outa yer own shoe like ya used to when you were up to yer tonsils in drink! Not good enough now for ya?

      Reply

Add New Comment