TheJournal.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Poll: Do you feel safe using an Irish taxi?

Last night’s RTE Prime Time Investigates unveiled corruption and criminality in elements of our taxi industry.

Image: James Horan/Photocall Ireland

LAST NIGHT’S RTE Prime Time Investigates – entitled Dodgy Cabs Ltd. – has sparked a serious debate about the taxi industry in this country.

Reporter Paul Maguire uncovered a sector where one in seven licensed drivers had a criminal conviction and revealed corruption in the NCT system where seriously defective taxi vehicles were allowed to pass the road worthiness exam in return for a cash bribe.

The controversy about the regulation and licensing of taxis in Ireland raged on into debate show Frontline and is still top of the radio agenda this morning.

But how do YOU feel about the taxi industry after last night’s exposé? Have your say here:

Do you feel safe using a taxi in Ireland?


Poll Results:






Strong response to Prime Time’s exposé of the Irish taxi industry>

Read next:

Comments (27 Comments)

  • Being from a smallish town there is a good chance that when I get into a Taxi I KNOW the taxi driver. I have never had reason to be afraid of a taxi cab or driver and even in the city have never had a problem. If taxi companies are bribing the NCT crowd then shouldn’t the NCT also be investigated? One more point, what about all the honest Taxi drivers who are attacked by drunks and or criminals and robbed of their takings and in a few cases, their lives. Let the regulator prosecute the wrong doers but then again…How many government officials are actually DOING their jobs?

    Reply
  • i feel sorry for honest taxi drivers who are given a bad name because of those assholes on the telly last night.i would say this is only the tip of the iceberg.lets just wait and see will anything be done or can we already answer that one ? its too easy now to be a taxi driver and half them dont even know where they are going.i think we should have something like they have in london where you must sit an exam and are asked questions on the quickest way from A to B, that should help somewhat towards having decent,hard working drivers who take pride in their job not being tarred like the others who have other jobs or are only in it to make a fast buck

    Reply
  • Paul 17/05/11 #

    I think the taxi regulator should step down as she looks more like the bank regulator who did not know what was going on in the banks

    Reply
  • What we need is a taxi regulator, then everything would be ok because nobody ever heard of a regulator failing to regulate… oh wait….

    Reply
  • Well not now :O

    Reply
  • I have come across some seriously dodgy ones all right……my faith in the driversa has been seriously eroded, not by the programme more by my observations in recent months expecially.

    Reply
  • I have not had any problems of note taking taxis in recent years. I would like to avoid bangers but can one reject an old banger in a queue of taxis?

    Reply
    • You should be a able to choose the vehicle you enter. There used to be a queue system in Galway where you had to go to the top of the queue but that was abandoned when the local drivers wanted to get ahead of the foreign drivers. Personally, i only get into a cab that is associated with the main firms in the city as you know who to call if you’ve lost something or if you have to make a complaint. You don’t have this luxury if you go with an independent cab.

      Reply
    • you are entitled to take a taxi of your choice wether that taxi is first or last on the rank and altough this will probably cause a row between drivers it is your right to choose once you have a valid reason for refusing to get into any other car. valid reasons include, unsafe car, dirty car, dirty/smelly driver etc

      Reply
  • I only use taxis from well know taxi companies, and I have never had a problem.

    I do believe the regulator is not doing her job, in any other situation a person would be fired. This is why we are in the situation we are in over paid people who have no idea what they are doing distroying other peoples livelyhood.

    Get rid of this woman and put in someone who know the industry.

    Reply
  • Nothing new in the programe that we in the trade didn’t know already.
    There are plenty more anomalies and scams out there in the certification of taxies but they are not as exciting .
    Taxi drivers have been informing the regulator , the gardai, RSA and the minister of transport but nobody listening -all trying to justify their jobs.
    On any given night you can be getting a lift in a car with a non national who probably shouldnt be working but can because of a loophole in the law,who has no training and area knowledge ,not insured,in a defective car and will probably rip you off.
    Very reassuring isn’t it
    OH and before anybody starts parroting on about about me sounding racist-did you see any Irish or EU drivers featured-No because we are policed rigidly and cant put a foot wrong or we are prosecuted..
    We are the easy targets at all times because we are the stupid irish who try to obey the law.
    ,

    Reply
    • well believe it canice mccarthy have heard a lot of stories listening to radio over the last few years and stilll nothing is done about it.people are afraid to say what your saying incase they are deemed racist but what can you do when its looking you in the face. i think using the racist card has been played to death and people like myself are sick of it,if they want to be treated the same, play the rules

      Reply
    • Purely anecdotal, but any trouble I or anyone I know has ever had with a taxi, has been in a car driven by a non-EU citizen.

      There is noting racist about comments like yours, Canice, when they are true.

      Reply
  • Last time I was in a taxi in Dublin, the driver side swiped a flat bed truck carrying sheets of glass in metal frames. The whole lot came crashing down on top of the taxi with me trapped inside. When I finally got out the driver still wanted his fee!
    I will never get into a taxi again!

    Reply
  • Gotta say I’ve been in both Irish and non-irish taxis that were both knackered and well maintained. Didn’t seem skewed one way or the other. I just started selecting better looking cars whenever possible.

    The big issue from the show was the apparent lack of on street enforcement. It can’t be too surprising that there are crooks out there ….so where is the on street enforcement?

    Reply
  • IS THERE ANY IRISHMEN DRIVING TAXI ANYMORE.THEY SEEM TO BE ALL NON NATIONALS,I FIND IT HARD TO GET INTO A TAXI WITH SOMEONE I DO NOT KNOW.EVERY PASSENGER SHOULD BE GIVEN A RECEIPT,IF SOMETHING GOES WRONG OR YOU LOSE YOUR WALLET OR PURSE YOU CAN TRACE THE TAXI , IT LOOKS TO ME LIKE IT IS ALL CASH IN HAND .WHEN THERE IS NO ACCOUNTABILITY THERE IS ALWAY;S DANGER.

    Reply
  • Chicago 17/05/11 #

    Gerry, if you want a receipt, ask for one, I always get a receipt, purely for the reasons u outlined.

    Reply
  • I’m more concerned about who I’m getting into the car with than I am about the car itself… Besides, I know nothing about cars and can’t tell from the outside whether it’s NCT approved or not, and if not, they’re hardly gonna tell the truth if you ask! If I need a taxi, there’s nothing else I can do about it. I don’t drive.

    Reply
  • Only ever take a taxt from my very reliable ABC Taxi’s who always respond quickly to a call out – at least I know who I’m gettimng into a car with

    Reply
  • I’ve always felt safe in taxis. But I always use Satellite Taxis, I’d never get into a cab at random.

    Reply
  • I for one would never trust a Belfast taxi driver since one kicked me and my boyfriend out in the early hours going home from the Kremlin Club. The driver had the temerity to object to us kissing in the back. Good God it’s 2011 not 1909.

    Reply
  • Of course I feel safe in any taxi. One in seven has a criminal conviction, so what. If they are driving a taxi and not in jail then they have served their time. A conviction is not a life time sentence. And so what if they don’t all pass the NCT, its only a money making exercise for the government. A pedestrian is far more likely to be hit and killed by a dodgy car than a passenger.

    This is just another example of the national broadcaster trying to scare the public.

    Reply
    • That depends on the conviction JimBob. Would you be happy to let your sister or mother get into a taxi alone, at any time of day or night, if there was even the tiniest chance the driver had ever been convicted of a sex offence?

      Reply
    • I certainly would not feel happy in that situation. People with serious convictions, like a sexual offence or a serious violent conviction should not be allowed to drive a taxi (or any other area where interaction with the public plays such a major role). However, if somebody was done for drunk and disorderly (or a similar minor conviction) 20 years ago, then that shouldn’t effect their ability to drive a taxi.

      The poll asked how safe I feel in a taxi, not how safe I feel my loved ones are. Short of pulling a weapon on me, I don’t think there is a lot that a taxi driver could do to make me feel unsafe.

      Reply
  • I would not feel safe in any taxi so I dont use them.

    Reply

Add New Comment