Zachary Hecht, global head of policy at TikTok. Oireachtas.ie

‘Not professional’: TikTok unable to give Irish viewing figures for dangerous driving videos

TikTok, Facebook and Instagram owner Meta, and Google, which also owns YouTube, appeared before the media committee today.

LAST UPDATE | 23 Sep

TIKTOK WAS GRILLED at the Oireachtas media committee today, with TDs and Senators telling the social media giant that their response is “not good enough”.

“I believe you guys are just off the hook,” said Sinéad Gibney. “Your self-regulating, your community guidelines, your content moderation systems, your significant investment, none of it is working.”

Evanne Ní Chuilinn asked the social media giant, “why can’t you spend money on AI that will refuse to upload the content in the first place”, instead of allowing videos that show illegal content to appear on the platforms.

“You’re failing,” she told TikTok, saying “you need to do better at not letting it be uploaded in the first place”.

Alison Comyn shared the sentiment, questioning the community guidelines referenced numerous times as the protective measures taken by the three companies – TikTok, Google and Meta, who appeared before the committee today.

It seems that nothing can break these community guidelines. What is seen can never be unseen and we’re not catching it fast enough.

On several occasions, TikTok was not able to provide more granular figures as to the number of views, and how many people in Ireland have viewed videos that showed dangerous content, including dangerous and wrong-way driving.

Chair of the committee, Alan Kelly TD, said that this was not “professional”.

“I don’t think you should appear in front of the committee without the figures,” Kelly said.

Facebook and Instagram parent company Meta, TikTok, and YouTube owner Google appeared before the committee to discuss the role that their platforms play in displaying content that shows, and in some cases glorifies, irresponsible or illegal activity. The meeting, Kelly said, was the ”most important meeting” that he has had as chair, because “it affects the whole country”.

The meeting comes after five teenagers were killed after driving a car the wrong way down the M9, seriously injuring three sisters and their seven-year-old nephew.

X was invited to the meeting, but did not make an appearance. 

Kelly noted that X had declined the invitation “despite multiple requests”, saying it was  “very disappointing”, “not a good sign for a company of that scale”, and that he “didn’t appreciate the manner in which they communicated that either”.

Zachary Hecht, global head of policy at TikTok was asked numerous times to contact his company to provide the specific figures during the course of the committee meeting, but was not able to provide the figures by the time it ended.

The figures they gave in their opening statement said that the vast majority (99.6%) of TikTok videos were removed before any user reported them, and 83.4% of those were removed before any views. 89.9% were removed within 24 hours of publication.

But committee members questioned the tech company several times on the viewing numbers by Irish people for the 16.6% of videos that were viewed before they were removed, as well as the 10.1% of videos that remained on the site for around 24 hours. 

TikTok did provide Irish figures on the number of videos that were flagged as depicting dangerous activities – which includes, but is not limited to wrong-way driving. In the first half of 2026, 42,000 videos were detected, and 1,600 specifically following the M9 crash. TikTok also said that around 2% of these indicate wrong-way driving – which would equate to around 30.

Google said that less than 10 Irish channels were removed from YouTube from the start of July to the end of August this year.

Meta said that 10 videos were removed from 1 December last year to 5 September this year, and since the M9 crash, 130 items that originated in Ireland have been detected that depict wrong-way driving, with 127 removed and two restricted for underage users.

Coimisiún na Meán also received some criticism, with Joanna Byrne raising an eyebrow that only 10 investigations into social media giants are currently ongoing.

“There’s more than 10 circumstances that need investigation. Never mind the half figures we’ve got from some of the social media companies alluding to thousands and hundreds of instances. 10 cases, seriously,” she said.

Profit making

TikTok previously said that it spent around $2 billion (€1.75 billion) on online safety. “In our Irish office, our people are our largest expenditure, and three quarters of the people in our Irish office are dedicated to the role of safety at TikTok,” Hecht said.

Responding, Kelly said: “Can you imagine the profits that are being made if TikTok can spend 2 billion a year on online safety?

“We’ve got a serious problem here. We can’t continue… We, as a country, are going to have to deal with it because we have to protect our citizens, protect our children.

“Which basically means we need to bring legislation, bring in regulations. You’re going to have to adhere to the regulations. The whole dial is going to have to change.

“Instead of countries trying to meet your requirements, you’re going to have to meet our requirements. And if you don’t meet those requirements over a period of time, based on an audit, based on a percentage of failing, well, then you’re going to have to be held criminally liable.

“When you set foot in the EU, you’ll have to come to Ireland to answer questions. That’s where this has to go because this is dangerous and illegal content.”

Kelly said that it came down to the fact that these platforms are not regarded as publishers – meaning they are not treated the same as outlets such as RTÉ and others who are responsible for harmful content. This, he said, “has to end”.

Opening statements

TikTok said in their opening statement to the committee today that the “responsibility for an act of criminality ultimately rests with the individual who chooses to commit it”.

“That does not however diminish the responsibility we have as a platform to ensure we are doing everything we can to prevent our services being used to promote or facilitate that behaviour,” the social media giant said.

The company said that the “priority is to prevent dangerous behaviour content from making its way onto our platform in the first place.”

Content showing dangerous behaviour, including wrong-way driving and gardaí chases, has gained traction on social media platforms recently.

TikTok has banned the account of at least one of the teenage boys who died in the fatal crash, and The Journal has reported on numerous other accounts on the site that show these activities.

TikTok had previously declined the invitation to attend the committee meeting, citing the ongoing inquiries by An Garda Síochána and Coimisiún na Meán. The company had offered a private briefing to the committee instead.

However, the social media giant subsequently confirmed that it would attend the meeting after the invitation was issued again by Kelly.

In the committee meeting today, TikTok said that “what matters is how [their policies] operate in practice and how [they] strengthen them”.

Their role also involves aiding with the deterrence of dangerous and criminal behaviour, they said, which involves supporting An Garda Síochána, and addressing underlying causes which requires a “broader cross-societal response”.

They “proactively” identify content that violates their policies upon upload – not just after content has been reported as illegal – using “technology and human expertise”, they said.

Meta said that they do not allow the posting of “high-risk viral challenges”, and that they “prohibit people from promoting, advocating for, or encouraging participation in them”.

They said that they are now treating driving against incoming traffic as a “prohibited high-risk viral challenge”, and will remove content accordingly. 

Their policies prohibit users from doing or sharing anything that is unlawful or which violates their standards, they said, adding that their policies are “calibrated to the risk” of content that encourages dangerous behaviour.

“Where a behaviour is likely to cause life-threatening injury and risks spreading as a challenge, we remove it; where content depicts dangerous driving without meeting that threshold, we restrict its visibility to users aged 18 and over,” they said.

The company uses automated detection, including hash-matching technologies that identify similar images, as well as keyword- and hashtag-based detection for illegal or inappropriate content.

Google said in their opening statement that content depicting dangerous driving, or any activity that poses “imminent risk of physical injury or death”, is strictly prohibited.

Videos on YouTube use “machine learning classifiers to rapidly and proactively detect and remove violative content”. Livestreamers are verified, and under 16s can only livestream if an adult is present.

The site also actively monitors online trends, to be able to “proactively update our detection systems against these emerging threats”.

In the first quarter of 2026, over 98.5% of the videos removed from YouTube were first detected by automated systems.

What are the laws?

Under the European legal framework platforms are not liable for illegal content on their services, as long as they act promptly to remove it as soon as they become aware of it. However, platforms cannot be required to monitor all content posted to check if it is illegal, according to media regulator Coimisiún na Meán.

However, platforms must have an easy way for people to report content, and the largest platforms must actively risk assess and mitigate risks arising from how they are designed and used.

Under the Online Safety Code, video-sharing platforms must restrict content that encourages behaviours detrimental to the health or safety of children, including dangerous challenges.

If a platform fails to do so, large fines can be imposed.

The EU Digital Services Act obliges platforms to adhere to and enforce their own terms and conditions. Where these terms prohibit content depicting criminality or promoting dangerous activities, platforms must remove that content.

Recently, the EU Commission published a proposal titled the “EU Kids Act”, which will introduce age restrictions for social media and new obligations on platforms to implement safety by design.

The Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill 2026 also includes a new power for Coimisiún na Meán to issue notices to a platform seeking information about compliance. 

View 98 comments
Comments Summary
AI-GENERATED
Readers debate whether TikTok and social media platforms bear responsibility for encouraging dangerous driving crimes
Where they land
Blaming tech algorithms versus holding individual criminals and parents responsible
What they think
Platforms amplify and glorify dangerous criminal behaviour for entertainment
Personal responsibility lies entirely with the individuals committing the crimes
Close
98 Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel

     
    JournalTv
    News in 60 seconds