Readers like you keep news free for everyone.

More than 5,000 readers have already pitched in to keep free access to The Journal.

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can help keep paywalls away.

Support us today
Not now
Thursday 30 November 2023 Dublin: 3°C
stevendepolo via Flickr/Creative Commons

New insolvency regime may not help troubled mortgage holders - Troika

The Troika has raised concerns about the effectiveness of the new personal insolvency law that is aimed at helping the country’s many distressed mortgage holders.

THE TROIKA HAS raised concerns that the new personal insolvency legislation may not be sufficient to address the problems of the average Irish mortgage holder in distress.

The long-awaited changes to the personal insolvency regime are expected to come into operation from the beginning of next month and have been billed as fundamentally reforming how personal debts are handled in Ireland.

Among the key changes are that it reduces the period of bankruptcy from 12 to three years and allows for a person with debts of between €20,000 and €3 million to a enter a personal insolvency arrangement if they become insolvent.

However a leaked European Commission document obtained by raises concerns about how this will help average mortgage holders who are struggling with debt.

The document says that the €3 million cap may be “unduly high” and could encourage banks, lawyers and insolvency practitioners to focus on “big-ticket cases” rather than deal with “smaller but much more numerous cases of average debtors, who are likely to be facing greater distress”.


The document notes that the average mortgage debt in Ireland is around €300,000 currently.

The Troika raises fears that the new insolvency service, due to be established within the first quarter of this year, could be overloaded with big cases at the expense of smaller but more numerous cases, many involving struggling homeowners.

The document warns: ”The efficiency of the system could also be jeopardised if the Insolvency service is overloaded with large complex cases, which could involve a multitude of interconnected debts concerning not only a debtor’s principal private residence, but also those associated with investment properties or sole-trader businesses.”

The new personal insolvency regime has been criticised in some quarters because any debt resolution process requires the agreement of the majority of a person’s creditors, meaning the bank retains an effective veto over whether to relieve someone from their mortgage debt.

Despite the concerns raised, the Troika does acknowledge that the new regime “should help facilitate a step-change in the resolution of unsustainable debts”.

- additional reporting from Gavan Reilly

Euroleaks: Troika wants less pay, more hours for public sector workers

More: Troika recommends cuts to specialist doctors’ salaries

Read all of’s ‘Euroleaks’ coverage >

Your Voice
Readers Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.